Originally Posted By: JHZR2
We checked out the A3 before we bought our rabbit. Sure, it was fancy, but it wasn't necessarily nicer. Dash materials appeared cheaper looking than the vw. I kind of don't get the premium compact segment... When you live in a place where tiny cars are the norm, maybe it is sensible. However, the price needs to be pretty darn low to justify not moving a segment up.
I didn't read too closely, but I'm assuming the a1/s1 can be had in awd while the polo and other little VWs aren't. That would be a differentiator. But most of these cars ( like, say, the Acura ilx)? No thanks. For a few bucks more you can get a far better, more substantial car, and for a lot less money, you can get almost the exact same car.
I agree. The Encore and Verano make sense, especially if you watch the options. $30k base for an A1? I wouldn't consider one.