Anyone upgrade from XP to windows 7

Status
Not open for further replies.

PSS

Joined
Mar 10, 2005
Messages
175
Location
NW Indiana
I'm planning on upgrading to windows 7 from XP. Am I correct that every old program must be reinstalled?

If that is the case I am planning on just adding a second hard drive and installing a clean version of Windows 7 on it. Then I can reinstall whatever I am still using instead of having lots of old junk still hanging around.
 
It is not possible to upgrade from XP to 7 unless you go from XP to Vista, and then Vista to 7.

It will have to be a clean install with all your apps reloaded.
 
I don't think I have had any problem with a program that worked on XP not working on 7. Definitely a clean install!! I think you will like windows 7.
 
Before you decide to upgrade (Do a clean install, best way), what specs does your system have? There is a certain point where you don't want to upgrade, and it would be better to just get a new computer with Windows 7 already on it, or build one.
 
I upgraded my Sony Vaio from Vista to Windows 7 and absolutely hated it. Some parts were cool but i hated the way everything looked and left so i went back to Vista literally that same day. Maybe i'm just used to the simple way that Vista works.
 
I've done three machines now in the past month or so. All from XP to 7. Our main Dell was 32-bit XP to 64-bit 7, and it did not ask whether I wanted to do an in-place upgrade. Clean install was the only option. The other two machines were 32-bit XP going to 32-bit 7 and they both asked whether I wanted to do an in-place upgrade or a clean install. I thought there was no in-place upgrade option from XP, but I was asked on the two machines. I did a clean install on both.

All three are running great...better on 7 than they were on XP. I love the new interface on 7. I didn't care for Vista, and don't care for it on my work computer, but I love 7.
 
Originally Posted By: Nick R
Before you decide to upgrade (Do a clean install, best way), what specs does your system have? There is a certain point where you don't want to upgrade, and it would be better to just get a new computer with Windows 7 already on it, or build one.
If your system has less than 1GB of RAM, I would not suggest upgrading. Just stay with XP....Windows 7 seems too "flashy" to me, from the demos I've seen set up at Best Buy.....thinking my next system will simply have Ubuntu or something....with perhaps a Windows XP partition/dual boot for those couple apps that do not work under Ubuntu/Wine...
 
Originally Posted By: Artem
I upgraded my Sony Vaio from Vista to Windows 7 and absolutely hated it. Some parts were cool but i hated the way everything looked and left so i went back to Vista literally that same day. Maybe i'm just used to the simple way that Vista works.


Huh? Vista and 7 use the same basic "Aero" interface, only a lot more polished. I'f you'd used it longer, you would have noticed that it runs a lot faster than vista does too. 7 is easier to use than Vista is. The taskbar at the bottom? You can change that to look normal, or at least show the words. Right click, click properties, under "taskbar buttons" click and select "never combine".
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted By: dparm
It is not possible to upgrade from XP to 7 unless you go from XP to Vista, and then Vista to 7.

It will have to be a clean install with all your apps reloaded.


As Hokie pointed out, this isn't true. I performed this task on my circa 2004 Dell Dimension 4600 a few weeks ago. 32-bit XP to Win7 32-bit. No problems. I like it better with Win7. That desktop has 2.5GB RAM. Clean install is the only way to go. Also, I wouldn't rely on the Transfer Wizard for your files though.
 
Originally Posted By: benjamming
Originally Posted By: dparm
It is not possible to upgrade from XP to 7 unless you go from XP to Vista, and then Vista to 7.

It will have to be a clean install with all your apps reloaded.


As Hokie pointed out, this isn't true. I performed this task on my circa 2004 Dell Dimension 4600 a few weeks ago. 32-bit XP to Win7 32-bit. No problems. I like it better with Win7. That desktop has 2.5GB RAM. Clean install is the only way to go. Also, I wouldn't rely on the Transfer Wizard for your files though.


I think dparm was talking about in-place upgrades. It's been said that you cannot do an in-place upgrade (that is, upgrading the OS while keeping your installed applications and data in place) from XP to 7. Everywhere I've read about upgrading, it's said the same thing.

The 32-bit upgrades I did seemed to allow me to to an in-place upgrade from XP to 7, though as I said, I never chose that option, instead preferring a clean install. Had I chose the in-place upgrade option, I'm not sure what the process would be, but it does seem to be counter to what I've read.
 
Originally Posted By: Nick R
Originally Posted By: Artem
I upgraded my Sony Vaio from Vista to Windows 7 and absolutely hated it. Some parts were cool but i hated the way everything looked and left so i went back to Vista literally that same day. Maybe i'm just used to the simple way that Vista works.


Huh? Vista and 7 use the same basic "Aero" interface, only a lot more polished. I'f you'd used it longer, you would have noticed that it runs a lot faster than vista does too. 7 is easier to use than Vista is. The taskbar at the bottom? You can change that to look normal, or at least show the words. Right click, click properties, under "taskbar buttons" click and select "never combine".

I was wondering the same thing. After you change the task bar to display words instead of just the icons, there is not much difference in the interface.

Heck, if you're so inclined you can make Win 7 look very similar to XP. I just cannot fathom why someone would go back to Vista considering 7's speed and reliability. I've got Vista business on my desktop still and the only reason it's not upgraded to 7 is because I don't use it much and one of the handful I programs I use on it won't function in Windows 7.

Originally Posted By: bepperb
Clean install, definitely. If you turn off user account control I think most people would prefer Windows 7.

I wouldn't turn off UAC. 7's UAC is much less annoying than Vistas (as that was a chief complaint microsoft wanted to address when developing 7). If UAC annoys you, just set it to its lowest level without turning it off. That way the only time you get a prompt is when a program wants to make changes and you are free to make changes to the system yourself without being bothered.

You could run into problems later if you ever want to set up a limited user account and you've turned UAC off as you have to turn it back on to enable limited accounts. Problems in the form of file and installation permissions for some programs... at least that's how it was in Vista.

UAC was implemented and then reworked in 7 because of Micrsoft's security model. Programs that are "certified" to run on 7 (and Vista) should never need admin privileges when performing everyday tasks. That was the problem with XP. There were many programs that were written so that they required full admin privileges to function normally.

For example, on my machine there are only a few programs that require admin privledges to run properly and that is due to the nature of the data they access. Speccy (made by the same guys who make Ccleaner) needs admin rights. Ccleaner doesn't need admin rights to clean up your limited user account but does need to be elevated to admin (right click - run as admin) to clean up all temp data from the system folders and other accounts on the machine.

I'd recommend setting up a limited user account and using that over an admin account and only logging into the admin account when you need to make some changes. You don't even really need to do that as you can elevate any program to admin privledges or install programs on a limited account by supplying the admin password when prompted.

Limited accounts can help limit your vulnerability to malware. Additionally, if malware does get on the machine, using a limited account can (but not always) confine the damage mostly to the user account rather than system wide like using an admin account for everyday computing can.
 
Most win7 (at least 64bit) problems I have seen relate to older hradware drivers, like some printers, scanners, plotters. A coupl of apps need to be run in compataibility mode, so if you have strange problems, let the system diagnose the issue, and set the app to run in compat mode.
jp
 
UAC in Windows 7 is much, much better implemented than it was in Vista, at least in my opinion. I got so frustrated with it in Vista I turned it off, only to later discover than I had to have it turned ON in order to install/use some programs...Adobe Acrobat Reader for example. Yes that's right...it will not install under Vista if you have UAC turned off...or at least that was my experience. I got very frustrated with Vista in general and went back to XP...until I finally upgraded to 7. Don't know why I waited so long. 7 is very, very good.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom