Anyone experienced more MPG by running Exxon Synergy gas?

mobil.webp
 
i bought costco gas one time. we would burn half a tank on a specific trip using shell. the time I filled up with costco the car was down to a quarter of a tank. never again.
I run costo gas, shell, exxon, and sheetz. I see no real difference in fuel mileage. I think there can be some variations of the ethanol content, up to 10% means it could be 10% or it could be 8%.
 
Around here, EXxon (I call it ESSO) runs best in my Ford. Then Irving number two. I've gotten cat killing swamp water repeatably from other stations like Shell - even a big, busy Mobil near the interstate.

I am ay 27.1 mpg long term average** on Esso and QSFS 10W30, where previously I was at 23.3 MPG (L.T.A.) with Irving and 5W20 Castrol Edge.

**My L.T.A is over a 6 month/2250 mile period

- Ken
 
Last edited:
You get an additional 4% off Costco's gas prices if you have one of their credit cards. Doubt you are going to get more mpg using Exxon gas. Costco gas is top tier as well.

https://www.costco.com/fuel-promise.html
Top Tier has nothing to do with MPG and everything to do with the quantity (not quality) of detergents.

There is nothing preventing anyone from using Top Tier quantities (or greater) without paying Top Tier tithe. The whole point of TT is for the little guys to claim their gasoline is as good as Shell, Texaco/Chevron, Exxon, etc.
 
In my experience if MPG differs between brands it differs just as much depending on the distributor. Exxon in Huntsville used to be swill, reliable 10% MPG drop. Was fine in the next county over. Now there is no Exxon here.
 
What gasoline does Costco use?
I've thought that they use whatever gas is the cheapest at the time, which means you could be getting Mobil, Shell, or whichever brand is cheapest for them at the time.
All gasoline at the distribution center is the same. The additive packages are added per lic per truck right during the fillup.

Costco does it differently. They get a pure non additive gas from the distribution center. Then the additives are added by the Costco attendant right at the pump when the fuel is delivered. In the end shell, Mobil and Exxon gets the same gas as Costco does. The difference is in additives and when they are added.
 
All gasoline at the distribution center is the same. The additive packages are added per lic per truck right during the fillup.

Costco does it differently. They get a pure non additive gas from the distribution center. Then the additives are added by the Costco attendant right at the pump when the fuel is delivered. In the end shell, Mobil and Exxon gets the same gas as Costco does. The difference is in additives and when they are added.
Where do costco store the additive containers? Is it in a UST and added by pump? Seems not safe to be bopping out with a carboy and a hand crank transfer pump and poor maths capabilities - otherwize.
 
I suspect that most MPG difference is lost in the variability of driving conditions, routes and the person driving. Now if you could layout a real experiment (25+ full tanks of fuel), then maybe one could find a small difference. JMO. Ed
 
Not anything you can measure with the myriad of variables involved.
I would agree, brand to brand, same octane the difference would almost be lost in the noise.

Unless some "super detergent" would better keep the engine top tune.

I have been relying on high-humidity weather to keep my Ford from pulling timing and over fueling its high comp12.5:1 engine.
 
Depends on the car and in particular with a turbo the fuel map/trim ie the knock detection enrichment scheme/amount. Yes absolutely better fuel, higher AKI will get better MPG because less cooling enrichment dumps (which also can cause fuel dilution)

But yeah the average, medium compression NA car, there will not be a detectable difference as it's buried in the variables.
 
i bought costco gas one time. we would burn half a tank on a specific trip using shell. the time I filled up with costco the car was down to a quarter of a tank. never again.
The drop in mpgs is most likely related to one of the many other variables at play. I have been using Costco gas for years...it's the cheapest Top Tier 93 around, the additives are blended right at the pump. If it's good enough to track my car with it's good enough for cruising around town.
 
Depends on the car and in particular with a turbo the fuel map/trim ie the knock detection enrichment scheme/amount. Yes absolutely better fuel, higher AKI will get better MPG because less cooling enrichment dumps (which also can cause fuel dilution)

But yeah the average, medium compression NA car, there will not be a detectable difference as it's buried in the variables.
Even so you'll never make up the cost difference between premium/regular with a slightly bump in mpgs, it's at times almost a $1.00 more a gallon. Best is Costco where the variance is about $0.30 and *maybe* you'd make up that difference.
 
I run costo gas, shell, exxon, and sheetz. I see no real difference in fuel mileage. I think there can be some variations of the ethanol content, up to 10% means it could be 10% or it could be 8%.
I do love me some Sheetz E85....ummmmm....corn......
 
Even so you'll never make up the cost difference between premium/regular with a slightly bump in mpgs, it's at times almost a $1.00 more a gallon. Best is Costco where the variance is about $0.30 and *maybe* you'd make up that difference.
I said zero about cost.

Turbo = pay the piper one end or the other.

We suck it up no problem with a car that gets 35+ mpg hauling decent loads to and fro
 
In the 1(rarely)960s, gasoline marketers set their own standards and specifications for fuel. Some were blended to warm up engines quickly to get them to operating temperature. Others were blended to give better mileage on long term trips.

Those days are pretty much over. The EPA provides specifications that all marketers in a region must meet, so the existence of different formulations affecting mileage is very limited. About the only difference now is additive packages, which I doubt anyone would notice from tankful to tankful.
This deserves to be repeated. The only differences ALLOWED by federal regulation are in the additives. There may also be a difference in impurities (rarely). The EPA mandates gasoline composition for a given region at a given time.

I commonly see the same trucks delivering gas at Costco, Arco, Shell, etc. stations.
 
Back
Top Bottom