Originally Posted By: Quest
Originally Posted By: dwcopple
If the HP claim were true, they'd have better designed factory exhaust systems and mufflers, and the aftermarket would be DOA or SOL.
IMHO aftermarket designed mufflers and exhausts and all other so-called "bolt-on" device serve a different group of audiences out in this free market, and depending on which group of audiences (remember: they are the customers for these gadgets afterall) they are targeting, aftermarket mufflers and bolt-on exhausts will only take on 1 of the 2 outcomes: (a )provide a high performance exhaust that serves a specific (and oftentimes very narrow)RPM band with peak HP but compromised the other useable RPM range; or (b ) no perceiveable benefits at all and only makes noise/sound which is also a valid form of pollution.
Truth is: when it comes to the subject of exhaust and mufflers, etc. from the original engine designer's perspective: it's all about compromise: balanced between low noise/high comfort level, engine longevity and/or covering wider usable RPM range, with peak power output to be tuned to a specific RPM and frequency (Helmholtz resonance); or sometimes with dual resonance point. and so on and so forth. Also: deviating from the original engine's design criteria typically ended up with suboptimal power output and/or lowered in longevity and service life.
(* this subject can become very advanced and involving...*)
Fact of the matter is: too many so-called "aftermarket bolt-on" compromised on 1 or maybe more of these original goals set by engine designers to extract certain characteristics to please the customers out there, but at the expense of others.
I'll stop here from getting to far into this subject matter.
Q.
Perfect response. I was going to reply to dwcopple, but you beat me to it. OEM's do an excellent job in comprimising when designing items such as exhaust to meet regulations, durability, power, mpgm etc. The aftermarket does not have to meet all these criteria.