Amsoil severe gear 75-90

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Messages
179
Location
nonya
I changed out the rears in my 98 jeep about a month ago from Rotella 80-90 to Amsoil 75-90.Now the rear is starting whine at around 35-40 mph.Its always been very quiet,i;m thinking about switching back to the Roteela.Any thoughts:? TY
 
Another thing i noticed is the pinion seal in the frt rear started getting wet after changing to Amsoil.
 
Oil changed in the rears regulaly and everything was quiet,has over 100k mileage wise.I'm starting to think the amsoil might have moved some dirt around etc....thing is the Rotella oil looked nice and clean when i drained it.
 
Quote:


What would be the big differeances between these two oils?




It may just be a viscosity issue. Professionally I would have recommended the Amsoil 75W-110 or 75W-140, for a vehicle such as yours with 100K+ miles.
I wish I could find the viscosity for the Rotella. I didn't see it on the web. Rotella
The Amsoil SVG = Kinematic Viscosity @ 100°C, cSt (ASTM D-445) 16.4. Maybe Rotella is at the high end of spec. range....
 
Think there is anything to woory about? I have some 75-140 SG i could add to it,
 
I think Pablo is probably right about recommending SVT over SVG for your application. I don't know much about your differential gears. Is it a high offset pinion gear? Maybe the Rotella (mineral?) was able to travel the ring and the pinion better under light loads. Anything's possible, but at least you know you can go back to Rotella if you want. It seems to work.
 
I only have about a 1 pint left of 75-140.The rear only holds about 3 pints.What really puzzles me is above 40 its silent????I would think if there was a problem with the oil it would be noisy at all speeds.
 
Pablo please read this and give me your opinion on 75-90 vrs 75-140http://xterrafirma.com/index.php?name=PNphpBB2&file=printview&t=3075&start=15
 
After reading the info at Rotella site,it has a sulfer based additive.Isn't that poor compared to the Amsoil?
 
Quote:


After reading the info at Rotella site,it has a sulfer based additive.Isn't that poor compared to the Amsoil?




Almost all diff fluids have sulfur EP additives. I'm not sure the point of your link - is your diff a limited slip?

I maintain that your diff has some wear, the Rotella probably is a bit thicker than the Amsoil 75W-90 and merely masked the whine that is only audible at certain speeds (but still there). Either use a thicker Amsoil 75W-140 or switch back to Rotella. Eventually you will need a new differential - or most likely your pinion bearings will need replacing.
 
My point is if heavier oil just "masks" the niose why bother changing it.In the test info the Amsoil seems the best oil i could put in there,worn or not.If i'm thinking wrong here please correct me.
 
It is a very good oil but it cannot fix defects. You will prolong life if heavier oil is used.
 
Well i'm very disappointed,the rear was very quiet before this oil change! Now it is noisy and starting to whine at all speeds.I'm starting to think amsoil is junk!
 
Un fortuneatly i got sucked into "its costs twice as much so its gotta be good" the Rotella was only 3 bucks a qt!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom