Originally Posted by Snagglefoot
That was very interesting. Thanks for sharing. One interesting question would be, did the engineers who designed the oil control valve have any preference on the viscosity of the oil or does the feedback system adjust the amount of advance regardless of the viscosity.
I know in the case of the system Chrysler uses, which, on the HEMI, is only phasing the single camshaft, that temperature is a component factored into the fuzzy logic for determining rough viscosity (as is oil pressure) and so a gross departure from what the system expects can result in a code.
BMW's dual phasing system VANOS, which uses electronic solenoids and oil pressure, does not seem to be overly sensitive as they've spec'd everything from a fuel saving ILSAC 5w-20 to a 10w-60 in the same systems.
Given the wild variance in viscosity due to temperature, which is significantly more than what's observed between grades, these system simply cannot be intolerant in terms of absolute viscosity in operation. What they can be is sensitive to relative viscosity. That is, at say 180 degrees the system expects between 40-45psi and it sees 70, that could potentially cause issues or trigger a code if that's part of its program.