So kinda an off topic here on BITOG but I'll bet there is some good, knowledgeable folk around. The MIL noticed a leak in her home during some of the recent rains we received. It was just on one day, and seemed to disappear after the first day. Inspected the attic it looks like a single leaky valley with mild mold and no structural involvement. Inspecting the exterior the roof feels solid, shingles appear in good condition with no curling/buckling and well finished. Only had time for one "quote" at this point and they immediately (without assessment or even much introduction) went right to replacing the entire roof. Granted, the roof is approx 30 years old which everywhere I read seems to be a strong indication of replacement.
I have little to no roofing knowledge but I do have some/plenty of DIY time as well as a reasonable head sitting atop my shoulders. Seems if there is only one leaky spot and everything looks good, why wouldn't it be prudent to seal up the leak and monitor? Worst case is a new roof next season, right? Well, I guess WORST case would be the leaking getting worse over winter resulting in water damage, but monitoring should catch that early and allow me to add more sealer/tar, right?
I have little to no roofing knowledge but I do have some/plenty of DIY time as well as a reasonable head sitting atop my shoulders. Seems if there is only one leaky spot and everything looks good, why wouldn't it be prudent to seal up the leak and monitor? Worst case is a new roof next season, right? Well, I guess WORST case would be the leaking getting worse over winter resulting in water damage, but monitoring should catch that early and allow me to add more sealer/tar, right?