Originally Posted By: SlipperyPete
Originally Posted By: edyvw
Originally Posted By: itguy08
Originally Posted By: edyvw
Really? BMW, MB etc. are very profitable. Unions here are piece of cake compare to those in Germany and they are still profitable.
When VW was deciding to open factory between Huntsville, AL and Chattanooga, TN reason why they choose TN is better education, and they even pushed for UAW to unionize their workers. The State of TN was the one who jumped and said NO!
So that [censored] about unions you can sell to someone else.
Ford and GM are profitable as well. FCA is as well. But they have heavy union presence and that has a cost. They also have lots of commitments to their past workers (healthcare/pensions) that a lot of these other manufacturers don't have. Also the contracts they have with the unions. I'm sure Ford, GM, FCA would love to open a non-union shop somewhere in the USA but there is a reason they don't have any. I doubt it's simply "cheap labor".
I'd not use VW as an example of working well in the USA. Look up Westmoreland: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_Westmoreland_Assembly
Chattanooga voted to go union. It will be interesting to watch as a quick Google search seems that there is turmoil with the vote as well as VW's recognizing of the UAW.
Of course it has a cost. They have prior commitments? Well yeah. Only here in this country we argue how wages should be up, but we do not want unions, we want right to work states who by they way are what? at forefront of standard of living?
So no problems, if GM, Ford and FCA do not want to owe pensions, healthcare etc. we go to universal single payer HC system, pension system similar like in Germany etc.
Or we just take all benefits from workers but still claim how we want best from them.
Unions are not problem. [censored] products are.
How many of their own "brothers and sisters" did the UAW sell out by keeping quiet when Ford and GM started moving production of U.S. market vehicles to other countries? How many more jobs would we have if american companies made their U.S. products in the U.S.?
If it weren't for the unions, more jobs would have left the US.
Originally Posted By: edyvw
Originally Posted By: itguy08
Originally Posted By: edyvw
Really? BMW, MB etc. are very profitable. Unions here are piece of cake compare to those in Germany and they are still profitable.
When VW was deciding to open factory between Huntsville, AL and Chattanooga, TN reason why they choose TN is better education, and they even pushed for UAW to unionize their workers. The State of TN was the one who jumped and said NO!
So that [censored] about unions you can sell to someone else.
Ford and GM are profitable as well. FCA is as well. But they have heavy union presence and that has a cost. They also have lots of commitments to their past workers (healthcare/pensions) that a lot of these other manufacturers don't have. Also the contracts they have with the unions. I'm sure Ford, GM, FCA would love to open a non-union shop somewhere in the USA but there is a reason they don't have any. I doubt it's simply "cheap labor".
I'd not use VW as an example of working well in the USA. Look up Westmoreland: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_Westmoreland_Assembly
Chattanooga voted to go union. It will be interesting to watch as a quick Google search seems that there is turmoil with the vote as well as VW's recognizing of the UAW.
Of course it has a cost. They have prior commitments? Well yeah. Only here in this country we argue how wages should be up, but we do not want unions, we want right to work states who by they way are what? at forefront of standard of living?
So no problems, if GM, Ford and FCA do not want to owe pensions, healthcare etc. we go to universal single payer HC system, pension system similar like in Germany etc.
Or we just take all benefits from workers but still claim how we want best from them.
Unions are not problem. [censored] products are.
How many of their own "brothers and sisters" did the UAW sell out by keeping quiet when Ford and GM started moving production of U.S. market vehicles to other countries? How many more jobs would we have if american companies made their U.S. products in the U.S.?
If it weren't for the unions, more jobs would have left the US.