WRX Filter In Forester XT

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jun 25, 2015
Messages
5,731
Location
New England
I'm hoping to tap into the knowledge base here to save myself a little time, mess, and oil.
I have been screwing around with picking oil filters for my FXT for a while (don't like the flimsy blue ones the dealers use/sell) and just put a Subaru branded Tokyo Roki 15208AA170 on my car last weekend. This is actually the recommended filter for the 2015+ WRX, which has 2.0l DIT engine that is similar to the one in my car (rated for slightly higher max HP because it puts out the max torque up to a somewhat higher RPM). This is a shorter and wider filter than the blue cans and the black Tokyo Roki that came on my car, and I have read that this is due to tighter hood clearance on the WRX or because there was some kind of heating issue that the shorter filter solved.
Anyway, I figured that the engines were similar enough that I could use this WRX filter, which appears to be very well constructed.
With me being me, I had to start thinking too hard about it and wonder...well, this filter is about 20mm shorter than the two I mentioned above that I know are OK for the FXT. Is there any chance that the hollow metal tube that the filter screws onto (there must be a proper name for it) is SHORTER in the WRX than in my FXT to accomodate the shorter filter? Have I possibly caused the oil flow in my engine to be restricted because there is not enough clearance between the top of the tube (which I assume is the inlet for the oil, not sure) and the filter casing? The car is running great now, but that doesn't mean I might not end up being oil starved if I gun it for a long time or there is some other strange condition in the future.
Since the filter is top mounted, it really isn't a big deal to unscrew it when the car is cool, clean up a little oil, and measure the tube to estimate how much clearance there is inside the filter. But, if somebody here knows the answer to my question, so much the better for me.
Thanks in advance for any replies.
 
I appreciate your concern. Short answer, no way. The can is hollow so even if the engine prodruded halfway into the filter the oil would find its way 'round.

In other words the threads won't be blocking "the holes".

You should notice it turning a few times to get on the block. If the threads don't catch enough to rotate at least 2-3 full turns, they could rip out, if the baseplate is radically different.

But look how deep your filter is, and imagine how much stud really threads into it, by how many turns it takes to get on and off. Typical is about 5, IIRC.
 
Originally Posted By: Virtus_Probi
I'm hoping to tap into the knowledge base here to save myself a little time, mess, and oil.
I have been screwing around with picking oil filters for my FXT for a while (don't like the flimsy blue ones the dealers use/sell) and just put a Subaru branded Tokyo Roki 15208AA170 on my car last weekend. This is actually the recommended filter for the 2015+ WRX, which has 2.0l DIT engine that is similar to the one in my car (rated for slightly higher max HP because it puts out the max torque up to a somewhat higher RPM). This is a shorter and wider filter than the blue cans and the black Tokyo Roki that came on my car, and I have read that this is due to tighter hood clearance on the WRX or because there was some kind of heating issue that the shorter filter solved.
Anyway, I figured that the engines were similar enough that I could use this WRX filter, which appears to be very well constructed.
With me being me, I had to start thinking too hard about it and wonder...well, this filter is about 20mm shorter than the two I mentioned above that I know are OK for the FXT. Is there any chance that the hollow metal tube that the filter screws onto (there must be a proper name for it) is SHORTER in the WRX than in my FXT to accomodate the shorter filter? Have I possibly caused the oil flow in my engine to be restricted because there is not enough clearance between the top of the tube (which I assume is the inlet for the oil, not sure) and the filter casing? The car is running great now, but that doesn't mean I might not end up being oil starved if I gun it for a long time or there is some other strange condition in the future.
Since the filter is top mounted, it really isn't a big deal to unscrew it when the car is cool, clean up a little oil, and measure the tube to estimate how much clearance there is inside the filter. But, if somebody here knows the answer to my question, so much the better for me.
Thanks in advance for any replies.


Eat a snicker. Better?
 
Originally Posted By: eljefino
I appreciate your concern. Short answer, no way. The can is hollow so even if the engine prodruded halfway into the filter the oil would find its way 'round.

In other words the threads won't be blocking "the holes".

You should notice it turning a few times to get on the block. If the threads don't catch enough to rotate at least 2-3 full turns, they could rip out, if the baseplate is radically different.

But look how deep your filter is, and imagine how much stud really threads into it, by how many turns it takes to get on and off. Typical is about 5, IIRC.


It felt fine when I screwed it on, and it did take a number of turns before it was hand tight. The issue is that I cannot remember for the life of me what the hollow tube itself looked like, and my imagination is showing me mental pictures of it ending 1mm from the filter casing itself!
It will probably help if I take a close look at one of the other 15208AA170 filters I have laying around. But, your post has helped calm my mind, too. Thanks!
 
FWIW, I have poked around and found other Forester XT (SJ, 2.0l) drivers who have been using this WRX filter without problems. Everything seems completely normal with my car so far and I was feeling confident enough to order 4 more of these filters for about $4 each plus less than $8 total shipping on Amazon, like that under $6 unit price.
I also popped the hood on my daughter's new Impreza and saw that it has a Tokyo Roki 15208AA160 filter, which is the same one my car shipped with. I compared it to a Mazda-branded Tokyo Roki N3R1-14-302 filter I had purchased earlier and they looked very much the same to me, aside from the markings. The 160 is tough to find in the US, but Subaru dealers here and there supposedly carry them...I suspect that this readily available Mazda filter is the same thing, and it definitely has the higher (~23 PSI) bypass pressure that Subaru filters have.
 
Probably just talking to myself here, but I realized that I could just watch a video of an oil change for a recent FXT on YouTube to see what the oil delivery tube looks like. It is VERY short relative to the height of the filter and there is NO chance of the short WRX filter being an issue on the FXT.
I really like the Tokyo Roki/Subaru 15208AA170 filters, very solidly made and I am finding them wicked cheap on Amazon.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom