What's the Difference between API SL & SM ?

Joined
Feb 3, 2006
Messages
9,103
Location
MN
All of the Pennzoil Platinum I see has an API SM rating and all of the M1 and M1 PP has an API SL. So, what's the difference between the SL and SM...? [I dont know]
 

Turk

Thread starter
Joined
Feb 3, 2006
Messages
9,103
Location
MN
Yea, but it would be nice to know which additives and/or what else. [Razz]
 
Joined
Jan 16, 2003
Messages
4,478
Location
Southern California
One of the biggest differences is the lower level of ZDDP antiwear agent in SM motor oil to address autmaker concerns about premature catalytic converter falure from phosphorus "poisoning". (the issue of "premature" being whether the replacement converter is on the automaker's watch vs. the owner's) To compensate, SM adds an additional antiwear agent - typically molybdenum, though there are others to choose from. When SN is eventually released, levels of ZDDP will be reduced further. Base oils in conventional formulations were further enhanced from SL to SM. Many SL oils were a combination of Group I and Group II, with some upper tier conventionals being totally Group II. Virtually all SM conventional motor oils in 5W-20, 5W-30, and 10W-30 viscosities are at least Group II/Group II+ blends, with some being Group II/Group III blends whether they state "synthetic blend" on the labeling or not.
 

Turk

Thread starter
Joined
Feb 3, 2006
Messages
9,103
Location
MN
Interesting, I wonder if ZDDP should be an additive then ?
 
Joined
Jun 2, 2002
Messages
3,083
Location
Georgia/Retired
The differences as published by the API are as follows: SM is limited to .06 min/.08 max percent phosphorous. SL is limited to .10% max phosphorous. TEOST is limited to 35mg max for SM TEOST is not rated of SL. Sulfur is .5% max (0w/5w) for SM Sulfur is .7% max (10w) for SM Sulfur is not limited for SL. Engine test for SM is sequence IIIG Engine test for SL is sequence IIIF SM limits viscosity increase to 150% max at 100 hours. SL limits viscosity increase to 275% max at 80 hours. Cam wear using sequence 4A limited to 90 micron max for SM. Cam wear using sequence 4A limited to 120 micron max for SL. Bearing weight loss using sequence 8 is 26 mg max for SM. Bearing weight loss using sequence 8 is 26.4 mg max for SL. There are numerous other differences but they are measured using different test sequences and therefore not directly comparable. There is no published limit on the level of zinc additive that I know of.
 
Top