Originally Posted By: tig1
I suspect oil warranties are useless.
I agree, and think that they're virtually 100% marketing/advertising palaver. Two huge problems I see. First, if they decide that they want to mess with you, it will be very hard to win a disputed claim. As noted above, how do you prove you started the program "on time". And then, you'd have to have virtually flawless record keeping, proving strict compliance with their "fine print" requirements. How many folks actually do that on a sustained, long-term basis? Also, the details of such programs are entirely at the whim of the company offering them -- they are subject to none of the strict government oversight that applies to new car warranties.
Second, how many owners actually own vehicles for this long? Surely some do, but realistically, most don't. And they very well know that.
I think it's very, very safe for oil brewers to offer such "programs," secure in the knowledge that their probability of having to actually pay ANY claims at all is virtually zero.