OP, I feel your pain.
My wife got rear ended when I brand new Passat still had the paper plates on it. It was a low speed impact. The young guy was texting. His insurance paid up (Progressive), but they won't pay for OEM VW parts. I didn't want to hit up my own insurance company for this, so I made up the difference myself - about $500. Total repair was about $2,500, just for a new rear clip, paint, styrofoam impact beam behind the bumper, and the choose strip. At least the body shop did an outstanding job. Looks completely virgin.
Then not two freaking weeks later my wife and I stopped for a quick bite at a Carl's Jr. in Salinas while on our way to San Jose. We went inside to order. When we got back to the car someone hit the rear end in nearly the same exact spot!!!!!!!!!! WTH??!!!!
I told my wife if this happens a third time, the car will be sold because it must have some kind of weird karma or something.
Scott