# Tesla Truck will need power of 4,000 homes!

#### StevieC

https://www.ft.com/content/f5593480-d29a-11e7-8c9a-d9c0a5c8d5c9
Quote:

Last edited:
Here's what I posted 10 days before that... https://bobistheoilguy.com/forums/ubbthreads.php/topics/4577295/Re:_New_Tesla_Truck_-_500mi_Ra#Post4577295 Musk/Tesla not commenting on what's simply fundamental math (or coming out with what exactly their amazing new technology) is PT Barnum behaviour at it's best. I get ragged as a luddite naysayer, but facts are facts...
Originally Posted By: Shannow
Here's the tractive effort curves from Cummins... https://cumminsengines.com/uploads/docs/cummins_secrets_of_better_fuel_economy.pdf Given the close coupled electric motors, say 200hp for a first approximation...150KW makes the math easier. 500 miles at 60 miles per hour is 8.3 hours...1.25MWh of storage... Six of these...mira alto substation has nearly 400 of these cubicles at 210KWh each...

Half the "gross vehicle weight" will probably be the battery bank. What's the supposed max load weight and range before a recharge is needed? And recharge time? ... gotta be a while.

Re the solar powered claim... I looked up Central Tech Stadium, in Toronto...(It's in Bathurst Street, I drive around Bathurst a few times per year - next town along). Using google Maps, there's a total of 15,000 square metres available to play with. Using http://www.nrcan.gc.ca/18366 And 25% efficient solar cells, gives 1KWh of electricity available for every one of those square metres, making it a potential 15MWh per day generating station...enough for 12 trucks on my calcs, or 10 on the linked article. OF COURSE it has to be grid connected...to throw it into batteries and then reclaim it loses 10% up front, and costs of the order of 25c/KWh round trip. https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-storage-analysis-20/ But assuming he is battery focused...which he appears to be, needs to find a spot for 72 of those refigerator looking batteries, and drop the number of vehicles that can be fueled by one... But, as they keep saying, technology will fix all those things...

Originally Posted By: ZeeOSix
Half the "load" will probably be the battery bank. What's the supposed max load weight and range before a recharge is needed? And recharge time? ... gotta be a while.
Go to StevieC's original thread (my first link)...that's the stamtent of claims from Tesla...80,000lb, 500 miles, recharge in minutes (not days)

I don't buy that 1.6MW is 3-4000 homes but maybe.... I do think that hybrids would benefit heavy trucks in the long run, especially garbage, delivery, and similar trucks that start and stop. Electric tractors like the one in discussion may be useful for inner city and high traffic areas where idling and starting/stopping/varying load diesels contribute to pollution. I can't see that this is a solution for most mainstream OTR trucking. I haven't read enough to see that it's definitely being sold that way. 400 miles could be six hours of interstate or a couple days of local deliveries at far lower average speed. High low end electric torque, smaller engines, and electric braking might benefit OTR trucking as well, as battery and power electronics densify, but I'll believe that when I see it.

Here's Musk's Claim...
Quote:
As The Verge reports, the Tesla Semi promises to deliver a 500-mile range on a single charge. To be clear, that's 500 miles driving with 80,000 pounds of cargo loaded in the back. While carrying all that weight the Semi can reach speeds of 65mph up a 5 percent grade climb (diesel trucks only manage 45mph) and the Semi easily out-accelerates a diesel truck regardless of the weight being carried. Other impressive features Musk divulged included a 400-mile range achieved with only a 30-minute charge. Four independent motors on the rear axles allow Tesla to make it impossible for the Semi to jackknife. It also means you'll never have to change the brake pads, as most of the kinetic braking energy gets fed back into the battery rather than wearing the pads down. ....

The big question is of course, how much will this truck cost? Then you get into figuring the cost per mile/km and calculate that into the costs of shipping. I’m guessing that freight charges will go up. Perhaps Musk is counting on subsidies or credits for companies to buy electric trucks? I like the hybrid idea better. I wonder how a diesel electric truck would work out? It worked for ships and locomotives

Re the 3-4,000 homes, agree, it's more like 1,000 homes daily consumption. Even the 2MW transfer rate to shift 1 MWh in 30 minutes, is still only about 700 homes peak draw rate.

Originally Posted By: PimTac
The big question is of course, how much will this truck cost? Then you get into figuring the cost per mile/km and calculate that into the costs of shipping. I’m guessing that freight charges will go up.
Musk's numbers
Quote:
As for economics, Musk broke it down to a cost per mile. Simply put, a diesel truck costs \$1.51 per mile travelled taking into account the total cost of operation. The Tesla Semi only costs \$1.26 per mile, and that's carrying 80,000 pounds and travelling at an average speed of 60mph.
Look at the costs of operating a truck... http://www.freightmetrics.com.au/Calculators/TruckOperatingCostCalculator/tabid/104/Default.aspx I think he's banking on at least free electricity.

It went into service this week. 5% of the peak capacity for 5% of a day...pretty impressive eh ? No release on how much the SA Govt spend on it other than it was part of their \$550M "plan"...so I can only work of Lazard when trying to crunch the numbers.

With this new technology is it better for the government to pick the winner or the free market?

Think about how much electricity is already piped into your basic a wall mart center - this truck wont be too much of a burden. UD

Initially it seemed impressive, and I figured there had to be a catch. Bottom line there's no free lunch.

This truck will never work in the real world. Cool concept though...

That truck is pure vaporware and always will be. Maybe a prototype or two. Never will work out. From an environmental perspective, it will be responsible for more emissions (indirectly) than a diesel truck if the electricity to charge it comes off a predominantly fossil fuel based generation grid. And let's not even get into the environmental issues surrounding lithium mining indirectly behind it's gargantuan battery pack.

Originally Posted By: Mr Nice
This truck will never work in the real world. Cool concept though...
Disagree: This should be able to easily charge the truck!

Elon Musk is not P.T. Barnum, he is more like Edison or Tesla himself. He founded PayPal, he is creating cars that defy conventional wisdom at Tesla, he is working on a human vacuum tube transportation system like you see in The Jetsons or Futurama, and some people believe that he is also the anonymous inventor of bitcoin. If any BITOGers have grave concerns about the viability of his new trucks, they can contact him directly on twitter. Might get a highly-paid engineering job if you can show him where they're wrong.

Cujet, Who is responsible for setting up charging stations at truck stops and having the dedicated parking area ? Will the government pass some bull [censored] law requiring accommodations for Tesla trucks ?

Replies
14
Views
708
Replies
132
Views
5K
Replies
39
Views
4K
Replies
109
Views
8K
Replies
45
Views
6K