Tell me why not to buy a 2025 Nissan Altima

Jatco thats why. Get an Accord, Camry, or Mazda 6. All mid-sized sedans all better than the Nissan.
I won't dispute that. In fact the Accord Hybrid is among my fav's. However, the real world price difference can be staggering.

In a wide enough search radius, one can find heavily discounted Altimas, worth a 150 mile drive to pick it up. One cannot find that with Accord or Camry. $9K-$10K difference, same basic trim levels.
 
I would consider an Accord Sport. At least email your local Honda dealerships Internet sales and let them fight it out. Ya never know...
Another nice car is the Mazda. Lotta car for the $$.

Good luck and good on you for helping your son. That's huge.
I'm working the Honda angle as well.
The Mazda 6 is long gone. It would otherwise be a good option.
 
I've driven a bunch of them as rental cars. I'd rate them as acceptable. But if I were shopping that category of car, I'd choose an Accord or Camry over an Altima. An Altima should be much cheaper to buy than the Accord or Camry, so that's something to consider.
 
We have had many Nissans/Infinitis in the family; not one has let us down. Actually, we had a 1990 Pulsar 1.6L that skipped a tooth and bent the valves; no problems since that one. I had to send the head out for a valve job and then put it back together for my little brother.
 
Last edited:
Na non complicated engine, and change the cvt fluid often.

My brother bought the na engine version in 2022 and he's been changing the cvt fluid every 30 K miles. He bought it because his wife requires a comfortable seat and soft ride for her back. She likes it a lot. They have over 70 K miles on it now and it's still going strong.

There's is only one trim level up from the cheapest. I hate the sound system in it, and find it nosies than my 2016 CR-V EX.

So, if your not into music while driving, their ok.
 
Here is why not to buy one: it's overpriced for what it is, it's expensive, it comes equipped with a subpar CVT, and Nissan is a company in distress that is going down. There are plenty of better options out there if you want a sedan.

The only reason to buy one: you get a crazy good deal on one, like way bellow invoice, and you get a crazy good financing deal. For an all-around gravy deal I'd put up with a CVT and some other Nissan specific oddities.
 
An Altima with the 2.5 would be a good car. Altimas are objectively good cars (if you change the transmission fluid). Their buyers often lead to the reputation they had.

Too bad Nissan killed them off after this model year
 
We've rented several over the past few years.
Call us crazy, but when we want something comfy, fuel efficient and simple to understand/operate, it's the best on the rental lot.
I'd echo the maintenance mentioned above. As long as you get the NA version and stay on top of trans fluid changes, you'll be fine.

Also, if you are fine with downsizing a little, the Sentra is also a great option and is still available with a manual transmission.

If we were in the market for a new vehicle, the Sentra/Altima would be on our shortlist.
 
Life changes and I find myself in a position where I need to sell my HAH to my older son. I guess I don't really need to, but he is two years into a mortgage on his house, has just given us our second grandson (February) and is working full time at decent wages and also going to nursing school, which he will complete in October.
The 2012 Accord I passed on to him has died a sad death.
He needs a ride, so being a kind and helpful father (sucker?) my thinking is to sell him the HAH at a friendly price and buy a new car for myself.
I don't really need a hybrid these days, having given up a fifty mile round trip commute since I retired.
An Altima SV is compellingly cheap, like five or six grand less than a new Camry or HAH. It does look pretty nice inside and out and should deliver good, if not hybrid fuel economy.
What do all of you think?

I'd say go take a look at it and see if you like it.
My experience with the Altima is limited to a rental, years ago.
The same year that I bought my '12 Accord (and you did too,) Mrs. Tdbo and I vacationed out west.
In Vegas, I rented a '12 Altima, and drove it up to Yosemite, and down the coast to LA.
We put over 1200 miles on that car in 10 days.
I really liked the car and the way it drove.
However, the car is really a value proposition. It just didn't have the solid feel that an Accord or Camry did at the time.
The real issue for me was the CVT. I didn't like the feel. While we were in the park, something happened while we were going up an incline. The CVT started making some strange noises and there was a noticeable difference in the way the CVT behaved the rest of the trip. It behaved okay, but was somewhat abrupt at times, and when pushed hard made that same noise again. It did not do that prior to the incident.
However, we are discussing a rental with over 40K that had been ridden hard.
Regardless, IMO, the CVT really is the weakness in the vehicle.
When we got back and were looking for a car that year, I did like it enough to end up at a Nissan dealer and negotiate a deal on one that was over 3K less that I paid for the '12 Accord. I remembered that trip through Yosemite, remembered the way the vehicle responded, and ended bailing on the deal.
The good news is that from the written accounts that I have read, the CVT's Nissan uses are vastly improved. If you go that direction, I would certainly treat the CVT as a potential trouble spot, and adjust your maintenance regimen accordingly to account for that.
If the numbers work for you, go for it. However, understand the trade-offs involved.
 
KIA K4 for $23k. See if you can keep that 2.0L alive with the "correct oil and filter" It will be an exciting journal to read on these hallowed pages.
I have driven a few new Altima loaners when I had a Rogue Select in for service. Never too impressed.

Screenshot 2025-06-18 103407.webp
 
Back
Top Bottom