The main point is that no one here has tried it, so no one can really say whether it will work or not. Its expensive, $30 a quart I think, which is probably the main reason. The other is that most of us are too obsessive and couldnt imagine never changing oil again. From what I understand the company has been around a long time, so there must be some success somewhere or he never would have lasted this long. So give it a shot, I would, but I have 200+ quarts of oil to use before I try something like that.