startup wear index?

[Pantdino]

I'm pursuing the issue of cold start wear and gather that moly, boron, zinc, magnesium, and phosphorus are the additives that prevent that. I looked at the VOA's of 9 oils on the site, and if you add the numbers for those elements you get a total PPM they represent in each oil.

6 of the oils have numbers between 2000 and 3000, the outliers being Castrol GTX 5W30 at 1550, Redline 5-40 at 3700, and Havoline Synthetic 5W40 at 4850 (!).

Does this number have any validity as a reflection of how much cold start wear the oil will prevent?

Thanks for all your excellent responses!

 

[Pantdino]

I just read elsewhere on this site that magnesium is a detergent, not an anti-wear additive. So the Havoline Synthetic 5W50 number is actually 3700, as it has 1143 of magnesium. (!)

 

[Motorbike]

quote:

---

Originally posted by Pantdino:


6 of the oils have numbers between 2000 and 3000, the outliers being Castrol GTX 5W30 at 1550, Redline 5-40 at 3700, and Havoline Synthetic 5W40 at 4850 (!).

Does this number have any validity as a reflection of how much cold start wear the oil will prevent?

---

Nope it does not affect start up protection in any huge way . Pumpability and additives that adhere to the internal parts while shut down and not picked up through spectro analysis does though .

 

[Chris]

You want Esters then.

 

[haley10]

quote:

---

Originally posted by Chris:
You want Esters then.

---

Maybe. My older truck (not oil filter related) has no startup noise even with a lighter weight syn. It's quieter than with a heavier weight dino. This is especially true if it sets for several days.

I have thought that Esters may explain it.