OVERKILL
$100 Site Donor 2021
I was assuming it was in an anti-static sleeve if NVMe style. The SATA ones are pretty rugged.Might cause ESDS issues depending on packing material.
Last edited:
I was assuming it was in an anti-static sleeve if NVMe style. The SATA ones are pretty rugged.Might cause ESDS issues depending on packing material.
Are we talking about the same thing here? NVMe SSD's don't have an enclosure, only the SATA ones do. It kinda sounds like you are talking about conventional spinning disks?In general, how much torture a given
SSD drive can take varies according to the nature of its enclosure. Some will let you drive a car over them. Others might be designed to handle just a short fall off a desk, and not much more
The OP wasn't specific in whichAre we talking about the same thing here? NVMe SSD's don't have an enclosure, only the SATA ones do. It kinda sounds like you are talking about conventional spinning disks?
There isn't an SSD on the planet that shouldn't survive a fall off a desk, they are like a stick of RAM.
On the left is an NVMe one, on the right, SATA:
View attachment 74775
But you said SSD.... Both drives I posted are SSD's, one's just NVMe, the other SATA. Both have no moving parts. I could throw them across the room and they'd both survive without an issue.The OP wasn't specific in which
type of drive and I replied to him and not your NvMe post.
Yes, @bunnspecial has posted a lot of great info on this issue with the M1's.There were some reports of excessive writes to the integrated NVMe SSDs on the new M1 MacBooks/Mac Minis. However, streaming doesn’t hit storage. Compute(CPU and if you have one, GPU) and bandwidth is more important.
SSDs are far more resilient than HDDs for sure.But you said SSD.... Both drives I posted are SSD's, one's just NVMe, the other SATA. Both have no moving parts. I could throw them across the room and they'd both survive without an issue.
SSDs are far more resilient than HDDs for sure.
But are not fool proof as you suggest. Nobody would throw SSD drives across the room and expect them to survive.
Come on.........
No problem here.I've worked professionally in IT for over 20 years. I'll gladly throw that Kingston across the room right now, plug it into a a USB connector and it'll work. There's nothing that's going to be shock impact damaged inside an SSD, that's the 2nd biggest benefit of them, the primary of course being the massive speed increase over a spinning disk.
Now, if I go put a .308 round through it, that's going to kill it, because I'm destroying the PCB, but just like with a stick of RAM, as long as you aren't bending it, breaking the solder joints on the PCB or destroying it with ESD, they are incredibly durable. This goes doubly for those securely mounted inside a protective aluminum housing like the SATA ones.
I'm not saying they are "fool proof". They are vulnerable to certain conditions/exposures (like ESD) and of course they can suffer a component failure like any other piece of IT equipment. However, they are not vulnerable to shock impact unless you reach the point of physical damage to the PCB or its components, which requires considerable force given how light they are.
No problem here.
I just handle those kind of components with care.
Linus and Electroboom did a video on ESD, it’s actually very very hard to outright kill hardware with even absolutely ridiculous levels of ESD. Granted, you still should be careful and they can’t really test if the lifespan was affected but it was impressive the amount of abuse the components could take.I've worked professionally in IT for over 20 years. I'll gladly throw that Kingston across the room right now, plug it into a a USB connector and it'll work. There's nothing that's going to be shock impact damaged inside an SSD, that's the 2nd biggest benefit of them, the primary of course being the massive speed increase over a spinning disk.
Now, if I go put a .308 round through it, that's going to kill it, because I'm destroying the PCB, but just like with a stick of RAM, as long as you aren't bending it, breaking the solder joints on the PCB or destroying it with ESD, they are incredibly durable. This goes doubly for those securely mounted inside a protective aluminum housing like the SATA ones.
I'm not saying they are "fool proof". They are vulnerable to certain conditions/exposures (like ESD) and of course they can suffer a component failure like any other piece of IT equipment. However, they are not vulnerable to shock impact unless you reach the point of physical damage to the PCB or its components, which requires considerable force given how light they are.
Linus and Electroboom did a video on ESD, it’s actually very very hard to outright kill hardware with even absolutely ridiculous levels of ESD. Granted, you still should be careful and they can’t really test if the lifespan was affected but it was impressive the amount of abuse the components could take.
I also caught my middle child using a 2.5” SATA SSD as a roller skate… it still works fine lol
That issue was resolvedThere were some reports of excessive writes to the integrated NVMe SSDs on the new M1 MacBooks/Mac Minis. ....
I've worked professionally in IT for over 20 years. I'll gladly throw that Kingston across the room right now, plug it into a a USB connector and it'll work. There's nothing that's going to be shock impact damaged inside an SSD, that's the 2nd biggest benefit of them, the primary of course being the massive speed increase over a spinning disk.
Little side note-
When I first set up my Mac Pro 1,1 that I use to use at work, I stuck a 256gb Kingston in it.
When the Mac Pro 1,1 was introduced, SSDs weren't really "a thing". The MP 1,1, 2,1(which is really a 1,1 with 3.0ghz quad core CPUs-the same ones my MP 1,1 has in it now) and 3,1 all use the same drive sleds, and I THINK a factory SSD sled existed for the 3,1 but it's quite rare. The only adapters I'm aware of are $$$. The situation is a little better with the 4,1/5,1, especially as SSDs were a lot more common when the 5,1 was discontinued, although when I set up my 5,1 I just skipped SATA SSDs all together and went straight to PCIe(mine is still running Apple branded AHCI SSDs, although I could and maybe someday will put NVMe in it). The SATA bays on my 5,1 have a couple of spinners scattered around them, but they're mostly junk bin ones I tossed in as things like scratch disks, and then one big one for on-board time machine.
In any case, as a temporary thing, I just shoved the SSD into one of the SATA ports on my 1,1 and left it there. I used it for a year, and didn't really even think about it because the computer never moved. When I pulled it apart to upgrade the CPUs, I realized the SSD was just hanging there, so went and grabbed some velcro for the SSD and the computer case and secured it with that. The drive is still there like that, and I have zero concerns about it.
Yup, I bought the little jumper harness and mine is just sitting in the spare ODD bay in my MP (mine is a 5.1)
That's awesome!!! LOL!The 1,1s are honestly fun machines-to me in some ways they're more fun to tinker with than 5,1s.
I mention all of that to lead up to something that I did in the optical bay of mine.
First of all, Apple shipped the 1,1 with ATAPI ODDs. They also, though, "hid" SATA headers on the LoBo, and most folks who were/are still using them(after El Capitan, the community around them sort of started falling apart since there was no way to coax something newer onto them) and wanted an ODD put a SATA drive in.
Needless to say, I did the same.
With that said, I had one particular PC at work interfaced to a GC-MS that at the time was running Windows 98. The I/O software supposedly didn't support anything newer, but I didn't want to try since I didn't have the install media for it.
Windows 98 USB drive support is iffy at best, and mostly non-existent, and data files ~1.5mb each, so it was hit or miss as to whether or not I could even fit a single file on a floppy disk(much less the multiple ones often needed). So, I did the only logical thing and put a ZIP drive in it.
I was sitting in my office one day fighting with my external ZIP drive and my eyes wandered over to the "computer parts shelf" from systems I'd torn apart and surplused where I had a pile of both ATA and SCSI internal ZIP drives. My eyes went back to the second optical bay in the 1,1, and a few minutes later my MP 1,1 had an internal ZIP drive. A strategically placed piece of wood held the optical bay door open. And yes, it worked perfectly in OS X El Capitan. The system recognized it for what it was, it read and wrote correctly, showed the appropriate icon on the desktop, and it ejected correctly.