Small weekend road trip report in the ID.4. Atlanta->Chattanooga->Atlanta

Joined
Aug 15, 2020
Messages
775
Location
Atlanta, GA
Took a quick weekend trip to Chattanooga to visit some of the sights and get out of Atlanta for a minute. This was my first "optimal" weather trip to see what I can expect for road tripping during non-winter months.

Longest leg was our outbound where we went Atlanta->South Pittsburg, TN to pay a visit to the Lodge Museum of Cast Iron and to pickup some factory direct Lodge pieces (5qt Dutch oven for mom and 3qt Dutch oven for home). 145 miles this leg and went from 98% SOC starting and ended at 25% SOC at arrival. Travel assist at 75MPH pretty much the entire trip and we didn't really hit too much traffic so it was pretty constant.

From there we went back to Chattanooga area and did a bit of local driving. Tennessee Valley Railroad Museum (definitely worth visiting for a quick steam locomotive ride), cruise around the VW Chattanooga factory, down to Chattanooga Choo Choo to grab dinner then back to the hotel. The hotel we chose has an EVGo station which is convenient but slow and expensive (I'll get to that later). I only charged to 80% that evening because there are L2 chargers at Ruby Falls (Blink) and at Incline Railway (Chargepoint) and I figured the two stops would get me to 100% for the trip home.

Return we moseyed our way back towards Atlanta from the hotel hitting the sights in order to make our way towards Atlanta instead of bouncing back and forth. Pulled an always be charging at Ruby Falls (Blink) and Incline Railway (Chargepoint) to get to 100%. Due to time limitations we were not able to go to Rock City which was unfortunately because the Incline Railway was a serious letdown and took much longer than anticipated.

2nd longest leg was our return from Chattanooga->Atlanta . 117 miles this leg and went from 100% SOC starting and ended at 42% SOC on arrival. Same as outbound with Travel assist at 75MPH pretty much the whole way, hit a couple 5-10 minute slowdowns.

Efficiency & charging stats:

Total trip miles - 341
KWH consumed - 115.9
mi/kwh - 2.94
MPGe - 99.18 (~12.7% above EPA HWY estimate)
Cost - $39.68 ($.1164/mile) - thank you EVGo for inflating the crap out of this.
Theoretical max range - 214 miles. (5.45% degradation - 72.8 max battery capacity)

EVGo & Chattanooga charging situation:

EVGo gets their own section because of their slowpoke 50KW chargers. The one at the hotel apparently is throttled (or has some sort of issue) to 35-37KW which is reported widely on recent Plugshare check ins. At .35/minute this resulted in in outrageous cost of ~$.66/KWH, I was not too terribly pleased with the station I used and will most likely avoid their 50KW stations in the future unless in a pinch.

EA currently only has one station way east of town (Wal-Mart on Little Debbie Pkwy) and are building another one way east of town at the VW Chattanooga factory (looks like its going to be a nice one with small solar awnings/canopies over the chargers). This leaves you with two broken 50KW EVGo stations downtown and the 50KW unit throttled to 35-37KW at the Hampton Inn I stayed at. The stretch from the the closest Atlanta EA (Barrett Place in Kennesaw GA) to the Manchester TN EA (Wal-Mart) is ~170 miles but it leave little room for error (very cold temps, high speeds, mountain climb, etc.).

Overall:

Great trip overall. Because this was a mostly straight freeway route I used the VW Travel Assist pretty much the entire time and just sat back and supervised the drive and touched the wheel when needed. I used to be the freeway bomber in my ICE days, ya know the bunch of cars doing 80-90MPH. It's nice to just settle back at 75MPH which seems to get you mostly to wide open roads most of the time with the cluster of freeway bombers flowing through every 5-10 minutes. Kind of interesting to see the other side of that style of driving and I have to say it is far less stressful to just chill out at 75.

Couple pics of the adventures. Chattanooga has quite a bit fun bit to offer and highly recommend if you are passing through or are near enough to make a weekend trip.

White Light Bottle Eyewear Font


Train Wheel Cloud Sky Vehicle


Water Purple Fluid World Formation
 
Nice trip and driving report. Do you see charging costing more near the highways the way gas is jacked up? How long have you owned the ID.4 and what are your overall thoughts?
It's not really a freeway proximity thing for charging cost as most fast chargers are priced at same level through the state (at least in the Southeast).

EVGo is just a dumpster fire in Tennessee apparently. I could have slashed the overall cost in half had I gone out of my way to Electrify America whose only station is in East Chattanooga on the way to Knoxville which would have been a 20 mile detour for me. Not really a proximity to freeway type situation, it was just the EVGo was slow to charge and charging by the minute vs kwh so it turned expensive fast. Imagine a gas nozzle only delivering 1 gallon per minute but charging $6-$7 per minute instead of charging by the gallon.

I know that stretch very well. That is not economical by any means.

Now knowing how bad the EVGo stations are in that area I probably would have done the out of the way trip to Electrify America to save a bit of $$$. I was going for convenience with the EVGo station at the hotel and it ended up not being economical at all. Electrify America needs to put something in on I-24 on the west side of Chattanooga to be honest.
 
Nice trip and driving report. Do you see charging costing more near the highways the way gas is jacked up? How long have you owned the ID.4 and what are your overall thoughts?
Just under 7 months with the ID.4. I bought a slightly used example w/15k miles so ended up with a fully loaded model (AWD Pro S Gradient) for the price of a new base model RWD model but didn't get tax credit or free Electrify America charging.

Honestly I have been quite happy with it and would give it an 8 out of 10. When it comes to hard product it is built beautifully, its the software and a few little design oversights that drop the 2 points. Software should start to be addressed soon so if that goes well I will push it to 9 out of 10. I need to do a 6-7 month review of the bad boy. Overall though I have been quite pleased with it.
 
Took a quick weekend trip to Chattanooga to visit some of the sights and get out of Atlanta for a minute. This was my first "optimal" weather trip to see what I can expect for road tripping during non-winter months.

Longest leg was our outbound where we went Atlanta->South Pittsburg, TN to pay a visit to the Lodge Museum of Cast Iron and to pickup some factory direct Lodge pieces (5qt Dutch oven for mom and 3qt Dutch oven for home). 145 miles this leg and went from 98% SOC starting and ended at 25% SOC at arrival. Travel assist at 75MPH pretty much the entire trip and we didn't really hit too much traffic so it was pretty constant.

From there we went back to Chattanooga area and did a bit of local driving. Tennessee Valley Railroad Museum (definitely worth visiting for a quick steam locomotive ride), cruise around the VW Chattanooga factory, down to Chattanooga Choo Choo to grab dinner then back to the hotel. The hotel we chose has an EVGo station which is convenient but slow and expensive (I'll get to that later). I only charged to 80% that evening because there are L2 chargers at Ruby Falls (Blink) and at Incline Railway (Chargepoint) and I figured the two stops would get me to 100% for the trip home.

Return we moseyed our way back towards Atlanta from the hotel hitting the sights in order to make our way towards Atlanta instead of bouncing back and forth. Pulled an always be charging at Ruby Falls (Blink) and Incline Railway (Chargepoint) to get to 100%. Due to time limitations we were not able to go to Rock City which was unfortunately because the Incline Railway was a serious letdown and took much longer than anticipated.

2nd longest leg was our return from Chattanooga->Atlanta . 117 miles this leg and went from 100% SOC starting and ended at 42% SOC on arrival. Same as outbound with Travel assist at 75MPH pretty much the whole way, hit a couple 5-10 minute slowdowns.

Efficiency & charging stats:

Total trip miles - 341
KWH consumed - 115.9
mi/kwh - 2.94
MPGe - 99.18 (~12.7% above EPA HWY estimate)
Cost - $39.68 ($.1164/mile) - thank you EVGo for inflating the crap out of this.
Theoretical max range - 214 miles. (5.45% degradation - 72.8 max battery capacity)

EVGo & Chattanooga charging situation:

EVGo gets their own section because of their slowpoke 50KW chargers. The one at the hotel apparently is throttled (or has some sort of issue) to 35-37KW which is reported widely on recent Plugshare check ins. At .35/minute this resulted in in outrageous cost of ~$.66/KWH, I was not too terribly pleased with the station I used and will most likely avoid their 50KW stations in the future unless in a pinch.

EA currently only has one station way east of town (Wal-Mart on Little Debbie Pkwy) and are building another one way east of town at the VW Chattanooga factory (looks like its going to be a nice one with small solar awnings/canopies over the chargers). This leaves you with two broken 50KW EVGo stations downtown and the 50KW unit throttled to 35-37KW at the Hampton Inn I stayed at. The stretch from the the closest Atlanta EA (Barrett Place in Kennesaw GA) to the Manchester TN EA (Wal-Mart) is ~170 miles but it leave little room for error (very cold temps, high speeds, mountain climb, etc.).

Overall:

Great trip overall. Because this was a mostly straight freeway route I used the VW Travel Assist pretty much the entire time and just sat back and supervised the drive and touched the wheel when needed. I used to be the freeway bomber in my ICE days, ya know the bunch of cars doing 80-90MPH. It's nice to just settle back at 75MPH which seems to get you mostly to wide open roads most of the time with the cluster of freeway bombers flowing through every 5-10 minutes. Kind of interesting to see the other side of that style of driving and I have to say it is far less stressful to just chill out at 75.

Couple pics of the adventures. Chattanooga has quite a bit fun bit to offer and highly recommend if you are passing through or are near enough to make a weekend trip.

White Light Bottle Eyewear Font


Train Wheel Cloud Sky Vehicle


Water Purple Fluid World Formation
Does it drive like a VW? I sold cars and worked as a lot tech for a local family's owned VW dealership back in the day.
 
Does it drive like a VW? I sold cars and worked as a lot tech for a local family's owned VW dealership back in the day.
Like a heavy VW - AWD tips the scales at ~4800 pounds. Its very competent handling for its weight but you aren't going to be keeping up with a GTI/GLI in the curves.
 
Holy crap, that charging cost sucks. $.35 a minute for that kind of speed is nuts. That's enough to skew the cost at that level that I think I could beat the cost for drive at least slightly with premium in the GTI. I've found electric for us to be overall much more economical and obviously that charging company is an outlier. That said the ID.4 has a lot more space than the GTI. I really like how the ID.4 drives and found it to be very comfortable. We'd have one right now in the wait didn't end up being so long. Any used prices I found at that time were a bit inflated here.
 
Holy crap, that charging cost sucks. $.35 a minute for that kind of speed is nuts. That's enough to skew the cost at that level that I think I could beat the cost for drive at least slightly with premium in the GTI. I've found electric for us to be overall much more economical and obviously that charging company is an outlier. That said the ID.4 has a lot more space than the GTI. I really like how the ID.4 drives and found it to be very comfortable. We'd have one right now in the wait didn't end up being so long. Any used prices I found at that time were a bit inflated here.
It was just the charger I used that inflated that cost because it was priced per minute but was a quite slow charger. EA (Electrify America) can max out at 4x the speed and probably would have finished charge in ⅓ the time of the EVGo station, 95% of the trip charging cost was at EVGo. Had I gone out of my way to EA the charging cost probably would be 1/3rd of what I paid - knowing what I know now I would have gone to EA instead.
 
It was just the charger I used that inflated that cost because it was priced per minute but was a quite slow charger. EA (Electrify America) can max out at 4x the speed and probably would have finished charge in ⅓ the time of the EVGo station, 95% of the trip charging cost was at EVGo. Had I gone out of my way to EA the charging cost probably would be 1/3rd of what I paid - knowing what I know now I would have gone to EA instead.

Oh absolutely, I get that. EA is by far the best choice for a VW.
 
Oh absolutely, I get that. EA is by far the best choice for a VW.
EVGo has higher speed stations elsewhere - just not in Tennessee apparently. Looking at their network there it seems like its mostly 50KW units. Here in ATL they have a number 100-350KW units and I have gotten good speeds out of them so not an EVGo problem, just their old slow charger problem in TN.
 
Back
Top