@INTJ, I replaced it with another P1, same filter PL14610, hoping it doesn't tear!
I chose to stick with it again mainly because of the AAP sale that includes the P1; it was either that or a Chinese undersize "consolidated" filter that I didn't want to use. Also, I like the textured grip sandpaper coating.
I just wish they'd have oil change specials that include the Purolator Synthetic, which doesn't have the tearing issue.
Anyway, it's nice to see another on-topic post in this thread! Although trolls can be fun sometimes though, and thanks to them for keeping the thread alive hahaha