Headlight lenses on my 10-year-old Tacoma with lots of highway miles were starting to get a bit cloudy and sandblasted. I'd heard the 3M kit that you use with a drill, worked pretty well, so I decided to try it. It is available at Pep Boys, Autozone, etc., as well as online. It comes with a buffer that goes in your drill, and several sanding discs. You start at 500 grit, then 800, then a 1600 or 1800 (can't remember) "Trizact" pad that you use wet, then an orange "egg crate" foam pad with rubbing compound.
The results were perfect. The lenses look new again. I'd say it was worth the $30 for the kit, especially since I still have sanding discs left over. I need to do my fog lamps, too.
I'd recommend this one that you use with a drill, over the ones you do manually. The results will be more professional with the drill kit.
It did take a while. I probably spent around 90 min. or more on each one.
Before:
After:







