Originally Posted By: TXMXTruck
Originally Posted By: OVERK1LL
Just a few things:
1. He's already bought the computer.
2. MSI is garbage, so I'm not surprised.
3. Many on-board video solutions have dedicated VRAM w/access to shared memory when needed. See: DVMT.
4. Unless we are talking about integrated SiS graphics from 1996, you won't notice any difference in "clarity" between on-board graphics and a dedicated card. His board has an AMD Chipset, meaning its integrated graphics are ATI. Not garbage. And he won't notice a difference in regular use.
Or, refer to page 1 of this thread. I know he already bought the computer and I posted that I checked the specs of his machine. If you had done so, you would know that he has nVidia 9100 integrated graphics. This is the slowest Geforce 9 chipset out there and it is fine for an office type machine. As he has a quad core processor, I'd still go for the add on card.
Also, if you re-read my post that you quoted, the replacement video card I purchased for my daughters machine is an MSI/Radeon. The former budget card with the screaming fan was an Asus.
1. I was responding to this part of your post:
"
Pop open your case before buying and it should be obvious if you have the correct slot available to add one of these newer graphics cards."
I hadn't gone BACK through the thread (I've posted in it before too) to see that you had previously posted. I assumed, based on this statement, that you hadn't.
2. I see that now. But why does him having a Quad-Core processor factor in to you recommending him having a PCI-E video card?
3. He still won't see a video quality difference between his on-board and a stand-alone card. I saw AMD and assumed AMD chipset on the board (hence ATI graphics). I was incorrect in the chipset indicated, but that does not invalidate the point I was making.
4. And MSI IMO is still junk
I've seen more MSI board and card failures than ASUS, Intel (Foxconn) and Gigabyte combined!
That being said, the silent cards in general are great for machines that aren't used for hardcore gaming, but the user still wants the flexibility of a video card they can upgrade later. No fans to go bad or plug up and as long as the case has DECENT ventilation, they won't cook things. On the other hand, cases WITHOUT decent ventilation can be exciting.
I'm not disagreeing with the general nature of your post, just some of your statements are a tad bizarre.