Peak Toyota RED concentrate vs Toyota dealer RED

Joined
Feb 25, 2009
Messages
215
Location
TX
I always buy the concentrate and mix it because it's cheaper. I know that both are supposed to be P-OAT formulas...but are they essentially the same for 100,000 or so miles?
 

Jarpin

Thread starter
Joined
Feb 25, 2009
Messages
215
Location
TX
Replacement intervals aside...would this Peak® brand perform just as well as OEM in daily use?
 
Joined
Jul 15, 2020
Messages
146
Location
Raleigh Durham NC
Is there a Toyota red and pink. The wife’s Rav4 2017 came with pink. I have not seen Toyota pink in concentrate only 50/50. Is it available in concentrate?
 
Joined
Oct 13, 2008
Messages
15,645
Location
The Old North State
Replacement intervals aside...would this Peak® brand perform just as well as OEM in daily use?
Yes. Toyota Red is the older shorter service interval P Hoat AF. Peak OEM Red basically equivalent to longer service interval Toyota Pink SLL. Toyota says Pink SLL compatible with Red, but to get the longer SLL service interval, a total exchange/flush needed. Not concerned about interval, just do a radiator d&f with Peak OEM Asian OEM AF.
 
Joined
Jul 11, 2014
Messages
3,751
Location
Paradise of Florida
Toyota doesn't assume anything. Can't do a proper, whatever that means, flush because Toyota Pink is 50:50 only. Can flush it with 50:50 in place of water. But, I get all of it out with the radiator/block drains so no flushing is needed.
Toyota isn't the only automaker that cuts future intervals in half. Its called marketing. Lowering the cost of ownership with less maintenance in the beginning and not caring about what happens after the warranty expires.... trust your automaker foolishly!

My other car recommends normal maintenance for 100k miles, and then future maintenance after 100k recommends to follow the severe service interval.
 
Joined
Apr 27, 2010
Messages
14,288
Location
Suburban Washington DC
Can't do a proper, whatever that means, flush because Toyota Pink is 50:50 only.
That's why I use
81SCkk8381L._AC_SL1500_.jpg

and do half a dozen drain and refills with distilled water.
 

Jarpin

Thread starter
Joined
Feb 25, 2009
Messages
215
Location
TX
Thanks to everyone who replied. Ended up using the Peak® Toyota concentrate 50:50 with distilled water. for the new radiator replacement. Also added two of the Bar's Leaks® tablets for added protection against pinhole cracks.

Is it true that many auto manufacturers add those stop leak tabs from the factory to extend the initial coolant service interval?
 
Joined
Dec 26, 2005
Messages
24,302
Location
Upper Midwest
Is it true that many auto manufacturers add those stop leak tabs from the factory to extend the initial coolant service interval?
Toyota does not, neither does Honda nor Volkswagen. Only those manufacturers that have a systemic problem with the cooling system that cannot be corrected any other way. I would not use them on a properly functioning system in good condition. I can say that I’ve never used them on any of my high miles vehicles including my old Sienna.
 
Joined
Jun 5, 2003
Messages
26,228
Location
Apple Valley, California
Toyota does not, neither does Honda nor Volkswagen. Only those manufacturers that have a systemic problem with the cooling system that cannot be corrected any other way. I would not use them on a properly functioning system in good condition. I can say that I’ve never used them on any of my high miles vehicles including my old Sienna.
You spelled general motors wrong
 

Jarpin

Thread starter
Joined
Feb 25, 2009
Messages
215
Location
TX
Toyota does not, neither does Honda nor Volkswagen. Only those manufacturers that have a systemic problem with the cooling system that cannot be corrected any other way. I would not use them on a properly functioning system in good condition. I can say that I’ve never used them on any of my high miles vehicles including my old Sienna.
That's great that you never had to use them on your Sienna. Maybe you also have a 1MZ-FE. a couple of years ago, on my timing belt change, I tried to drain the rear side of the block of remaining coolant. The bolt was seized and I ended up twisting off the head that resulted in a tiny drip leak. I have no intention of tampering with the broken bolt at my mileage, so I use either the Subaru Coolant conditioner, or the Bars leak tablets. The timy leak is no more. I am using them for coolant pH balancing effect too.
Since the circulating particles are pliable and organic, there's less chance of them clogging the radiator or heater core.
 
Joined
Dec 26, 2005
Messages
24,302
Location
Upper Midwest
Yes my old Sienna has a 1MZ-FE. But nevertheless your question was about whether "many auto manufacturers" add the tablets to new production engines and the answer is that they do not. Only those that have issues that for whatever reason are unfixable.

And pH balancing is not a real thing. There are pH buffers in coolant and unless those are exhausted you aren't going to materially affect the "pH balance" of the mixture. This is marketing gobbledygook.
 

Jarpin

Thread starter
Joined
Feb 25, 2009
Messages
215
Location
TX
I can say that I’ve never used them on any of my high miles vehicles including my old Sienna.

I know what my question was, but I was explaining my rationale for using them in my particular situation, in contrast to yours.
 
Top