Parenting vs Genes

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Aug 15, 2002
Messages
2,441
Location
Indiana
Good life may offset bad genes
UGA substance use study

By Lee Shearer | [email protected] | Story updated at 11:59 pm on 2/22/2009

Even people with a gene that predisposes them to alcoholism or drug abuse are more likely to say “no” if they were raised by good parents, University of Georgia researchers have found.

Working with more than 253 black families in rural Georgia, the researchers followed youngsters over four years - from 11 to 14 years old.

About 40 percent had a gene that made them at risk for substance abuse, a gene connected to risk-taking.

But when researchers took parenting into account, the genetic effect vanished.

The study shows that both environment - parenting, in this case - and genetics play a role in health problems, said Steven Beach, a psychology professor and director of UGA’s Institute for Behavioral Research.

Beach worked with UGA family and consumer sciences professor Gene Brody and Robert Philibert, a professor of psychiatry at the University of Iowa. Their findings were published this month in the Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology.

Many studies have followed children over time to see how identified genetic risk factors influence their health and behavior. But the UGA scientists say theirs is the first study to follow youngsters over time to see how their environment influences a genetic risk factor.

Overall, 21 percent of the children in the UGA study had smoked cigarettes and 42 percent had tried alcohol by age 14. Five percent had drunk heavily, and 5 percent had used marijuana - and drug and alcohol use was much higher for kids with the gene than for kids without it.

In families without much good parenting, kids with the negative gene were three times as likely to use alcohol or drugs than those who did not have the gene, the researchers found.

But children with the gene - who also had engaged, supportive parents - were no more likely than kids who didn’t have the gene to drink or use drugs, the researchers found.

The researchers judged parenting based on factors such as how much time parents spent with children, communicating with them and helping them with homework.

People often uses phrases like “the gene for alcoholism,” or the gene for this or that kind of cancer. But reality is much more complex, Beach said.

All health problems likely are the result of both complex genetic and environmental influences, he said.

“There are a lot of genes that have a little effect, and we all have some of them,” Beach said. “The bigger story is finding the things that help us deal with the risk that we have.”

People can’t switch out their genes, but people can change environmental factors such as parenting, Beach said.

“We’re interested in the part of it that we can do something about,” he said. “In some ways, it’s a confirmation of what people have been thinking for a long time - the parenting connection is really important.”

Originally published in the Athens Banner-Herald on Monday, February 23, 2009
 
Genes (IMO) are very over-rated WRT things like heart disease and cancer.

Follow the money as they say.
 
I firmly believe in genetic influences. They're not "all governing" ..but I'm sure it's a matter of YMMV. One merely has to look at physical characteristics that are passed on to melt most denial of the profound impact it has. What would make anyone think that, all other things being equal, it would stop with height, proportion, eye color (perhaps), hair color ...etc..etc..etc.

That being said, a therapist that was told the advancement in pharmaceuticals could put him out of a job...

"While physiology absolutely effects behavior ...behavior effects physiology". What you do ..or what happens to you, can surely impact who/what you end up being.
 
I don't think there's any denying that if identical twins were seperated at birth, one child was given to capable, financially secure, compentent and loving family who really wants children, and the other was given to a family that is the complete opposite in every way, regardless of their genetic makeup, there are going to be serious behavioral differences between the two kids by the time they're adults. If you're raised by thugs, you're going to become one even if every genetic component in your body says you should be an upstanding citizen.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom