Perfectly normal; two months old = Jan 11 at the pump = up to as early as November 11 out of the refinery.
You are deeply and clearly into Winter Fuel Formulation territory in any area where overnight lows can go below freezing in your oil market (there are 11 in North America, the fuel market is more than one State in total area).
Winter fuel is more volatile to avoid cold start issues; the volatile compounds have less energy (BTUs) and get poorer mileage compared to summer formula.
Although two month old fuel "isn't that old", it is old from a fuel market perspective ... utilizing all available gasoline storage facilities in North America, including the strategic reserves, we can store gas for a maximum of three months from the refinery input (pumped perhaps a week earlier, at most, out of the ground) to retail delivery, and it's very rarely that old. That's why retail gasoline prices vary on what amounts to a day-to-day basis.