NEW Vehicle Advice / Recommendations: Anyone? Subaru or Toyota? What says the gang?

There have been '24 and '25's with bearing issues too.
Not only Tundra. They are grenading in Sequoia too. They initially claimed it is only non-hyrbid.
It is the design of an engine. You cannot push obsolete technology for decades, and then wake up one day and design something that complex.
They had these issues with diesel engines in Europe 20 years ago, and ended up buying BMW diesels. They wanted to be part of the game, and engines were having broken pistons after 40-60k.
 
I had another RAV4 today 8,000 miles with bad shocks on it. Had to reject it for state inspection until the shocks come in for it. For some reason we have gotten in a bunch of new cars off the trucks with dead batteries too. Toyota needs to do better than this. I’m not sure if you read about all the new Tacoma they shipped with bad brake hoses so they had to stop sale of them and advise customers not to drive them if they owned one.

Toyota reps came out a few weeks ago and told us our dealership submits too many warranty claims as they don’t ever have issues with their products then we showed them proof in person and they are like oh.
I had to replace my 2020 RAV4’s rear shocks as well but at 105K miles which isn’t unexpected. Total cost was around $80 for Japanese made KYBs. I’ve never heard of shocks going bad a 8K, sounds like a bad batch. I did my front struts as well at the same time for an additional $150 just to have match things up. While the rear shocks were 100% shot, the front struts still had some life left to them.

I’m amazed at how easy everything is to DIY on these RAV4s. My 2012 Subaru Impreza is also very easy to work on; I just had to change out a shift solenoid in the transmission (at 155K) myself which only took me about two hours and $46.
 
I'm 6'7" 300+ so my observations are based on comfort for me

Yeah, the egress and ingress are more tight on the prior gen Accords as compared to the generation before that. I rented a 2022 Accord Hybrid in 2023 and while I really enjoyed driving it around the mountains in Southern California, getting in required some contortion and one time I whacked my knee pretty bad on the dash trying to get in fast. That alone decided for me that I would never own one. I don't know about the newest (current) generation, haven't tried one.

I've also rented a Camry Hybrid in the last few years, it is comfortable once you're in it, but the seat was low for my taste. I definitely felt like I was sitting down into it. I was able to achieve 58mpg on this car driving around Seattle and Whidbey Island, if anyone cares about such things. Considering I paid over $5 a gallon to fill it up before returning it, I was glad for this high fuel mileage at that time.

The Rav4 is the best selling car in America but I have not rented one of the latest generation models, they are new this year. The older ones were not great on interior space for a person of my size but maybe the new ones are bigger. They are competent drivers but boring and if you don't get the hybrid the fuel economy is not great IMO at the kind of speeds we drive here in Texas. (I think the new ones are hybrid only).

The Highlander is much more roomy and I would definitely recommend if you can afford it. They are expensive though. The lowest trim you can get the hybrid with is the XLE and such equipped is $48315 with no options. The very lowest trim, the non-hybrid LE is over $40K also.

Oddly the Grand Highlander Hybrid starting price is about $2000 lower according to the Toyota website. Reason seems to be that they offer the hybrid in an LE trim on the Grand Highlander.

I am a not Subaru fan personally. However the last time I sat in a Forester, I did find it roomy in the front seat area.

What about an Outlander? The new generation is pretty roomy up front, it was plenty for me. We drove them and liked them. It's based on the Rogue but without the wacky VC-turbo variable compression 3 cylinder. Our 2018 Outlander was dead nuts reliable. We considered replacing it with a 2024 Outlander PHEV, but we went all EV.

(However, we would consider a PHEV again in the future if the OEMs gave them more EV only range so that we only rarely used the gas engine around town. Begrugingly on my part, more enthusiastically on the wife's part)
Impressed w your writing...
 
Not only Tundra. They are grenading in Sequoia too. They initially claimed it is only non-hyrbid.
It is the design of an engine. You cannot push obsolete technology for decades, and then wake up one day and design something that complex.
They had these issues with diesel engines in Europe 20 years ago, and ended up buying BMW diesels. They wanted to be part of the game, and engines were having broken pistons after 40-60k.

I assume it's only a matter of time until there are documented issues with their twin turbo V6 engine, in every Toyota/Lexus vehicle it is installed in.

I wanted to like the new 6th gen 4Runner. I went and looked them over in person, and drove various trim levels. The cost-cutting was glaringly obvious, and the poor fit and finish. This on a vehicle built only in Japan, which traditionally has meant it was built to the highest Toyota standard. There has been a "Quality Control Hold" on their sale, presumably to address air-dams falling off while driving down the highway, and possibly the pathetic fit of the wheelwell flares on some models.

I am disgusted at the direction they seem intent on heading.
 
I assume it's only a matter of time until there are documented issues with their twin turbo V6 engine, in every Toyota/Lexus vehicle it is installed in.

I wanted to like the new 6th gen 4Runner. I went and looked them over in person, and drove various trim levels. The cost-cutting was glaringly obvious, and the poor fit and finish. This on a vehicle built only in Japan, which traditionally has meant it was built to the highest Toyota standard. There has been a "Quality Control Hold" on their sale, presumably to address air-dams falling off while driving down the highway, and possibly the pathetic fit of the wheelwell flares on some models.

I am disgusted at the direction they seem intent on heading.
Their fit and finish were not anything special before. My Sequoia is on par VW from 1994. But, it holds and I don't expect anything more from a vehicle that big that was $45,000 when new. However, to pay $80,000 for something assembled like my 1988 Opel Ascona, is absolutely insane. It is like they took that mindset that was present in American companies, which led them to bankruptcy: "whatever we sell, people will just buy it." It works for some time, but things catch up with you.
We will see what the 2026 Sequoia brings. They basically abandoned that segment with this Sequoia, which is basically a glorified 4Runner.
They should drop that solid rear axle for independent, drop the battery down, and offer a version without a hybrid.
That is if they fix that engine. At this point, they might just go B58.
 
Their fit and finish were not anything special before. My Sequoia is on par VW from 1994. But, it holds and I don't expect anything more from a vehicle that big that was $45,000 when new. However, to pay $80,000 for something assembled like my 1988 Opel Ascona, is absolutely insane. It is like they took that mindset that was present in American companies, which led them to bankruptcy: "whatever we sell, people will just buy it." It works for some time, but things catch up with you.
We will see what the 2026 Sequoia brings. They basically abandoned that segment with this Sequoia, which is basically a glorified 4Runner.
They should drop that solid rear axle for independent, drop the battery down, and offer a version without a hybrid.
That is if they fix that engine. At this point, they might just go B58.
It is truly a shame. A lot of younger folks have no idea. The American + Canadian "Big Three" were at one time the makers of some really nice , quality vehicles. From the mid to late 1950s well into the late 1960s , Ford / GM and Chrysler put together some really nice rides. If one does not remember or have never seen any of them, go to some local car shows. Yes, most of the vehicles there will be "restored" to like new condition. But one can still get a good idea by looking at the quality the interiors were made with. You will really see something if you stumble across what are known as "survivor-grade" classics that still have the original factory paint and interiors. It seems like sometime around 1972 the management of those three companies lost total track of what got them the success they were enjoying. The Big Three made some of the most horrible /cheap designed vehicles ever from about 1973 until sometime in the late 80s. They finally woke up and after having their clocks cleaned by all the high quality foreign cars that people wanted and were buying up all across North America. They had little choice but to start to return to using quality interior materials and stepping up overall design qualities in a desperate attempt (they are still in it now) to catch up to the imports. We sure need to hope the Japanese and other auto makers do not attempt to copy the poor/cheap take it or leave it stuff the Big Three tried to push off on its customer bases... They are still paying for that blunder. Sad part is regardless the quality, the cost of owning the stuff keeps going in one direction .... up up up.
 
That is a biggie for me. I hate the way every day seems to bring new technology that eliminates the ones we just are getting used to.

I had so much new technology shoved on me before I retired I have run from it ever since. I got so burned out having to keep learning all the new systems the company I worked for kept getting taken by.
Upper level managers kept retiring and then taking positions (consultant/sales) with those new companies. They would come back and talk our people into trashing our great/easy/workable systems and buy whatever the old managers they knew came around selling. I often wondered how much under the table money changed hands in all of that. It caused no end of frustration and extra hard work for no real value. I heard a lot of that was going on at the time. Yeah. I am certainly looking for the SUV we can find with the least amount of tech.
I was on a project 2 summers ago where my employer spent 3 mil on a system sold to us by a German co. The really amazing thing, I was on a call I so mentioned the system doesn’t work. The vendor said you are out of hours on this project. Someone on our side said to my co, who’s responsible for this product, who agreed to implement it? Crickets, and nothing more ever became of it to this day. The site operates without the system we paid for.

At any rate our next car will have more tech than we ever imagined (google and Alexa?). I’m ok with it, but I do take your perspective on day to day things. I’m good with the analog way of doing things.
 
Not only Tundra. They are grenading in Sequoia too. They initially claimed it is only non-hyrbid.
It is the design of an engine. You cannot push obsolete technology for decades, and then wake up one day and design something that complex.
They had these issues with diesel engines in Europe 20 years ago, and ended up buying BMW diesels. They wanted to be part of the game, and engines were having broken pistons after 40-60k.

Where did Toyota claim the issue only affected non-hybrids?

The safety recall excludes the hybrids because in the event of the engine grenading the hybrid system still allows for a limited continued operation of the vehicle thereby eliminating the "safety" issue encountered with completely losing power in the ICE only models covered under recall.

That said even the non-hybrids have electric power steering so while you would lose acceleration if engine grenades I presume you would still be able to steer to the side of the road with power assist?
 
Where did Toyota claim the issue only affected non-hybrids?

The safety recall excludes the hybrids because in the event of the engine grenading the hybrid system still allows for a limited continued operation of the vehicle thereby eliminating the "safety" issue encountered with completely losing power in the ICE only models covered under recall.

That said even the non-hybrids have electric power steering so while you would lose acceleration if engine grenades I presume you would still be able to steer to the side of the road with power assist?
In the beginning they only claimed “machining debris “ affected strictly ICE versions.
So, basically what you saying grenading engines in hybrids are left for customers to fight for? I mean, I can see Toyota doing that as they only do safety recalls voluntarily.
Not sure that helps their case.
 
In the beginning they only claimed “machining debris “ affected strictly ICE versions.
So, basically what you saying grenading engines in hybrids are left for customers to fight for? I mean, I can see Toyota doing that as they only do safety recalls voluntarily.
Not sure that helps their case.

I am not aware where they made that claim. Got a source? That would (bizarrely) suggest the motor's internals are different if being installed into a hybrid equipped model and therefore Toyota builds them on a separate assembly line that was unaffected with the machining debris problem.

Again, I believe Toyota made the claim there's no safety issue for the hybrid models (which is true) and therefore they aren't covered under the safety recall.

So yes for the hybrids if your motor grenades after the warranty expires, you are on the hook for the repair. Rare for a Toyota, but just another day on the freeway for a Ford, Jeep, or Euro brand owner...
 
I haven’t owned a Subaru in 20 years but after two I never went there again. Nothing bad about them, mine were quite good and served me well, but I found other vehicles for my use offered better functional matches.

We were pretty much a Honda family until seeing a slight decline in their quality starting 10 years ago. I won’t bash them, they still make good vehicles, but I had issues with 2 in particular and didn’t like what I was seeing.

So if between Toyota and Mazda, drive both. My son in law has a Mazda suv and it’s a very nice, quiet, comfortable vehicle. We have a RAV4h and it’s less tanky and handles a little more nimbly. Control surfaces on the RAV are easy-peasy, it hides all the things that must be going on, and just works. I will say again that the hybrid powertrain, as well as the extra ballast provided by the batteries, make this a very intuitive and fun vehicle to drive. The seats aren’t terribly sculpted and they do have a nice appointment of softer padding on the surface layer.
 
I haven’t owned a Subaru in 20 years but after two I never went there again. Nothing bad about them, mine were quite good and served me well, but I found other vehicles for my use offered better functional matches.

We were pretty much a Honda family until seeing a slight decline in their quality starting 10 years ago. I won’t bash them, they still make good vehicles, but I had issues with 2 in particular and didn’t like what I was seeing.

So if between Toyota and Mazda, drive both. My son in law has a Mazda suv and it’s a very nice, quiet, comfortable vehicle. We have a RAV4h and it’s less tanky and handles a little more nimbly. Control surfaces on the RAV are easy-peasy, it hides all the things that must be going on, and just works. I will say again that the hybrid powertrain, as well as the extra ballast provided by the batteries, make this a very intuitive and fun vehicle to drive. The seats aren’t terribly sculpted and they do have a nice appointment of softer padding on the surface layer.
Oh yes. We are going to be driving several different brands of SUVs when the wife gets back from her trip at end of the month. She is flying off to visit family in Tennessee first. I may do some on my own test drives while she is out of town. We are even going to look at Mazda and some others. Can't believe I am saying this one... she even wants to drive a Chevy Trax since she has been seeing them around. As unhappy as I have been with the way I feel Honda has been headed , we will probably even test drive a Honda CRV Hybrid. Our youngest son's in-laws have been driving Mazda SUVs for many years. They have a fairly new one right now I will be checking out soon.
 
I don't think ANY manufacturer makes a good car nowadays. Case in point: My mom's 2024 Toyota Cross. From day 1 when it would rain, the pass floor mat will get wet. Even in a car wash. She took it back 5X. " We can't find where where the water is coming from, but we can see the mat is wet. Bring it back another time " Yeah, their gonna run the warranty out, and that will be that. Honestly, I don't trust any manufacturer anymore. That's why I drive a 13' CRV, 03' Solara, 06' Camry. They'll run forever with little maintenance. Toyota WAS my last hope, but they are going in the toilet now. I'm fortunate enough to have had my enjoyment with late 60's- early 70's cars. Memories is all I have to offer you poor souls looking for a good car. My mom is devastated. I told her I'll drill the floor pan, and sell the car. Meanwhile, I'm driving her old 03' Toyota Solara. It just won't die. It's a shame:(
 
I don't think ANY manufacturer makes a good car nowadays. Case in point: My mom's 2024 Toyota Cross. From day 1 when it would rain, the pass floor mat will get wet. Even in a car wash. She took it back 5X. " We can't find where where the water is coming from, but we can see the mat is wet. Bring it back another time " Yeah, their gonna run the warranty out, and that will be that. Honestly, I don't trust any manufacturer anymore. That's why I drive a 13' CRV, 03' Solara, 06' Camry. They'll run forever with little maintenance. Toyota WAS my last hope, but they are going in the toilet now. I'm fortunate enough to have had my enjoyment with late 60's- early 70's cars. Memories is all I have to offer you poor souls looking for a good car. My mom is devastated. I told her I'll drill the floor pan, and sell the car. Meanwhile, I'm driving her old 03' Toyota Solara. It just won't die. It's a shame:(
That late 90’s, mid 2000’s does seem to be when engineers ran buck wild and bean counters were ok with it. We bought a 10 yo LS430 in 2016 and it turned into a self fulfilled prophecy. Virtually nothing broke in the last 8.5 years and the car will be 20 in 2 mos. And what did break is exactly like every other car on the forum (cupholder, pass mirror not tilting correctly, etc).

The other car being a 2007 has a true dual exhaust. Imagine getting sign off to do that?
 
I concur...like I said 03' Solara, 06'Camry, 13' CRV with the last of the good engines..........Then came the bean counters. I swear, you close the door on my mom's 2024 Toyota Cross, and you get scared thinking it might bend. The door is as thick as a beer can !
 
My mom's 2024 Toyota Cross. From day 1 when it would rain, the pass floor mat will get wet. Even in a car wash. She took it back 5X. " We can't find where where the water is coming from, but we can see the mat is wet. Bring it back another time " Yeah, their gonna run the warranty out, and that will be that. Honestly, I don't trust any manufacturer anymore
To be fair, that's a dealer problem. Dealer is failing to find the problem.

Have you looked into lemon law? I think it varies state to state, but perhaps you can force them to fix or replace.
 
I swear, you close the door on my mom's 2024 Toyota Cross, and you get scared thinking it might bend. The door is as thick as a beer can !
Cost cutting and all. But trying to keep costs down. At the risk of letting my inner Toyota fanboi out, this is like amongst the cheapest in class, no? Have to have expectations that match the cost. Now if you were talking about 4Runner or Sequoia, then yeah, you're right--but I think this is meant to be as cheap as possible.

My Corolla feels no different, however I'm starting to get 40mpg in a non-hybrid this summer, with me just keeping my speed reasonable. But I do wish it had more metal out back, I took one look at the "frame rails" (whatever you want to call the creases that make up the unibody) and realized I did not want to put in a trailer hitch. I've towed with other FWD's, installed their hitches, thought nothing of it--but this car, not enough car back there IMO.
 
Back
Top Bottom