you would want an oil with a jaso MA or MA2 but not MA1 rating..
since that oil doesnt list that spec, I would choose one that does.
JASO MA covers both the MA1 and MA2 range of specs.
JASO Explained Part 1: 4-Stroke
JASO Explained PART 1: JASO 4-Stroke Engine Oil Specification The Japanese Lubricating Oil Society or JALOS is the organization that regulates the performance of various motorcycle specific …www.mototribology.com
your statement is correct? But does not contradict my quoted post.
If the oil says MA1 avoid.
MA2 is preferred but some oils will only spec JASO MA and these are also usually ok. (I have not ever heard of any JASO MA oils that have caused issues have you?)
Jaso MA1 is the lower half of the Jaso MA spec and inferior for the OP's use.
An example would be Rotella T 15w40 it was Jaso MA, after updating the pds it is now JASO MA2.
So for a oil with superior frictional characteristics for a wet clutch choose JASO MA2.
JASO MA | JASO MB | |
Dynamic Friction Characteristic Index (DFI) | ≥1.45 and TD][TD]≥0.5 and TD] | |
Static Friction Characteristic Index (SFI) | ≥1.15 and TD][TD]≥0.5 and TD] | |
Stop Time Index (STI) | ≥1.55 and TD][TD]≥0.5 and TD] |
JASO MA1 | JASO MA2 | |
Dynamic Friction Characteristic Index (DFI) | ≥1.45 and TD][TD]≥1.8 and TD] | |
Static Friction Characteristic Index (SFI) | ≥1.15 and TD][TD]≥1.7 and TD] | |
Stop Time Index (STI) | ≥1.55 and TD][TD]≥1.9 and TD] |
With that said, doesn’t appear a simple Jaso MA rating has ever been detrimental to any of our cycles. I split wood last weekend but I think we’re splitting hairs here. Carry on.^^^ Yes, so if oil is only rated simply as JASO MA nobody knows which of the 3 separate specs it's actually meeting - it can be a mix of eigher MA1 or MA2. Which one(s) of the 3 specs is "bad" if it falls into the MA1 column?
With that said, doesn’t appear a simple Jaso MA rating has ever been detrimental to any of our cycles. I split wood last weekend but I think we’re splitting hairs here. Carry on.
Which bit is the FM?It does have friction modifiers in it. https://pqia.org/mobil-delvac-1300-super-sae-15w-40-heavy-duty-diesel-engine-oil/
That's what I was trying to say as well, if it's JASO MA/MA2, folks it covers both.What I'm saying, is if I had oil that was just rated JASO MA I'd probably just use it because there is basically no info that I can find to say don't use it because it doesn't totally meet MA2. It could be that nobody even makes oil that just meets JASO MA these days ... would have to do an extensive cycle oil comparison to know.
That's what I was trying to say as well, if it's JASO MA/MA2, folks it covers both.