MANN ML 1008 CUT OPEN

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Mar 12, 2015
Messages
34,930
Location
In the shop
Another filter from SubyRubieRoo:)

Looks ok for 4k oci i will say. No rust in can and jo dents this time
smile.gif


20181013_122607.webp


20181013_122621.webp


20181013_122645.webp


15394483328546382294226100994236.webp


20181013_122835.webp


20181013_122845.webp


20181013_122903.webp


20181013_122856.webp
 
Displaced bypass valve, again. Might as well be torn same thing. This might be the same filter, pics mixed up maybe, as it isn't used. Or it is meant it is good for 4k, which in this case it is not except for constant bypassing. Purolator made.
 
Originally Posted by goodtimes
Displaced bypass valve, again. Might as well be torn same thing.

How do you get that from these pictures?
 
Originally Posted by rooflessVW
Originally Posted by goodtimes
Displaced bypass valve, again. Might as well be torn same thing.

How do you get that from these pictures?

How do you not get it? The lip of the plate is over the edge of the recess. His other post shows how it should be.
 
Originally Posted by goodtimes
Originally Posted by rooflessVW
Originally Posted by goodtimes
Displaced bypass valve, again. Might as well be torn same thing.

How do you get that from these pictures?

How do you not get it? The lip of the plate is over the edge of the recess. His other post shows how it should be.

Just looks a little off center to me.
 
Originally Posted by goodtimes
Displaced bypass valve, again. Might as well be torn same thing. This might be the same filter, pics mixed up maybe, as it isn't used. Or it is meant it is good for 4k, which in this case it is not except for constant bypassing. Purolator made.



Pics mixed up with what exactly? I have only sent one Mann filter to 53', ever. And I don't see anything like what you are talking about. Though I didn't use it, I would have if I had the need for it.
 
The disc does look offset on the bypass valve. Put some water on top of the bypass valve and see if it leaks. If the sealing lip is large, it may still be sealing even though it looks offset (ie, not centered).
 
Originally Posted by SubieRubyRoo
Originally Posted by goodtimes
Displaced bypass valve, again. Might as well be torn same thing. This might be the same filter, pics mixed up maybe, as it isn't used. Or it is meant it is good for 4k, which in this case it is not except for constant bypassing. Purolator made.



Pics mixed up with what exactly? I have only sent one Mann filter to 53', ever. And I don't see anything like what you are talking about. Though I didn't use it, I would have if I had the need for it.


He showed another one with a disk out of the recess before. When you post pics it is easy to grab the wrong ones sometimes. So there are two now and there have been more before with opened bypass. I thought bashing Purolator was supposed to be in. This is a Puro made filter. The disk is out of the recess in the picture I don't know what could be clearer. Maybe I am detail oriented.
 
Originally Posted by ZeeOSix
The disc does look offset on the bypass valve. Put some water on top of the bypass valve and see if it leaks. If the sealing lip is large, it may still be sealing even though it looks offset (ie, not centered).


The gap even can be seen in the picture, above the sealing plate. This kind of flat spring doesn't have much side to side movement either. like the blue button bypasses which will seal all the time. Don't get the I don't see anything when it is in a picture clear as day.
 
Originally Posted by goodtimes
Originally Posted by ZeeOSix
The disc does look offset on the bypass valve. Put some water on top of the bypass valve and see if it leaks. If the sealing lip is large, it may still be sealing even though it looks offset (ie, not centered).

The gap even can be seen in the picture, above the sealing plate. This kind of flat spring doesn't have much side to side movement either. like the blue button bypasses which will seal all the time. Don't get the I don't see anything when it is in a picture clear as day.


I didn't say I saw nothing wrong - said it looks off center and test it for leakage. Pictures are sometimes deceiving.

Or look at it in the dark with a flashlight on the back side to see if any light can be seen though the sealing area.
 
Originally Posted by bobdoo
The off-center look is simply due to the camera being aimed at an angle to the centerline of the filter...


That would be the obvious answer. Nothing to get worked up over as I'll never use that filter as if i didnt cut it i would have crushed it
 
Originally Posted by ZeeOSix
Originally Posted by goodtimes
Originally Posted by ZeeOSix
The disc does look offset on the bypass valve. Put some water on top of the bypass valve and see if it leaks. If the sealing lip is large, it may still be sealing even though it looks offset (ie, not centered).

The gap even can be seen in the picture, above the sealing plate. This kind of flat spring doesn't have much side to side movement either. like the blue button bypasses which will seal all the time. Don't get the I don't see anything when it is in a picture clear as day.


I didn't say I saw nothing wrong - said it looks off center and test it for leakage. Pictures are sometimes deceiving.

Or look at it in the dark with a flashlight on the back side to see if any light can be seen though the sealing area.


Talking about the other folks who say they see nothing wrong, not you. It was said it's the angle last time it came up too. It isn't the angle because the disk fits down into the recess so it can't be shown covering the lip of the recess no matter what the angle is. I put the same picture up last time, and "53stude just cut another Puro made that also shows the disk nicely sitting inside it's designated recess.

IMG_3409.webp
 
^^^ Suggestion - don't quote me, than make a comment that sounds like you're addressing me when you're not.

If the disk is offset when it should instead be down inside the recessed area, then 53' Stude should be able to see some light through it, or it will leak water like a sieve if tested like I suggested earlier. But sounds like he's not interested in investigating.
 
Originally Posted by ZeeOSix
^^^ Suggestion - don't quote me, than make a comment that sounds like you're addressing me when you're not.

If the disk is offset when it should instead be down inside the recessed area, then 53' Stude should be able to see some light through it, or it will leak water like a sieve if tested like I suggested earlier. But sounds like he's not interested in investigating.


It was clear you were not saying nothing looked wrong. So why would I say you were. That is part of reading in context. If the disk is in the recess it is OK, if not it is going to leak, being open. Because it is not resting on it's sealing area but on the ridge. I can see it is not in the recess in the picture, even the gap is seen. There is no need to test anything I am comfortable with what I see.. This is the third one with the off bypass. The 45 record spring probably doesn't move side to side much if at all. I don't really care what '53 does or doesn't do on it. I am older than his father, already in mid career when he was born. I have plenty of Purolator old filters to look at that bypass construction, and already have. Don't need any advice on their build. I appreciate his good work and efforts, good hearted person, we all do our best and just have a hobby talking oil filters. Not a big deal to the rest of the world, believe me.

I used to drive a 59 Studebaker Lark to work, for years. Nice car with the small v8 for it's day, but a piece of junk compared to a modern car. Side comment.
 
Originally Posted by goodtimes
It was clear you were not saying nothing looked wrong. So why would I say you were. That is part of reading in context.


You could have read it wrong, and commented with a wrong response - I'm not a mind reader. It wasn't clear you were responding to everyone else but me. Just sayin' ... more clarity would be appreciated.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom