"Luke warm oil" question...

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jul 22, 2004
Messages
41
Location
Memphis, TN
If you live in a climate...say like Memphis TN...where the coldest temps in the winter never get below 0F..and probably never dip below 20F...is there any advantage to using an 0W oil over a 5W? At these temps, does an 0W grade provide better start-up protection than a 5W? Does on 0W provide better start up protection and initial drive away protection at 50F? 40F?
30F? 20F?
 
Well looking at graphs for Mobil 1 there is almost no difference (width of the line) between the 5W and 0W Mobil 1. There may be a bit more difference for a conventional oil but for the most part the practical difference is very little. I wouldn]t bother with the 0W where you are.
 
The 0w-, 5w-, 10w-, etc, part of the SAE viscosity grades defines the maximum allowable dynamic(absolute) viscosity at particular temperatures for each grade.

So roughly speaking, it defines the lowest temperature you should attempt to use that grade for.

The -20, -30, -40, etc, is defines the minimum/maximum, low shear-rate allowed kinematic viscosity at 100C(212F), and high shear rate kinematic viscosity at 150C. So roughly speaking, it defines the viscosity the oil should have at operating temperatures.

To determine the viscosity at some other temperature, you need it's viscosity measurements at two temperatures like 40C and 100C to get the oils viscosity index. Using that information you can get a good estimate of the viscosity at a lower temperature as long as it's not to close to the lower limit. Temperature/Viscosity Conversion Calculator(not ASTM)

For example, let's run some numbers for M1 and Mobil Drive Clean. (Viscosities in cSt)
code:

M1 0w30 M1 5w30 MDC 5w30(dino)

100C 10.3 10 10.5

40C 56 56 62

VI 175 167 159



0C(32F) 419.1 445.6 535

-10C(14F) 846 923 1144


So, in this case, down to 14F, the difference is probably negligible among the synthetics, but starts to be significant between the synthetics and the dino, but not enough to be concerned.

Hope that helps.

[ December 07, 2004, 05:09 PM: Message edited by: 427Z06 ]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top