Those Monstuhs look as if they would give some mud HELL! Can we get you to go thru a mud hole and see if they actually work?
I'm in the same boat with new tires as well. They're not ANYTHING close to what you have. Mine are General Grabbers, a touring tire. So far I am really liking them. My truck drives so much smoother (I had some cheapies on there before) and much quieter too.
Have you ever heard of Gateway Mudders, or CO-OP mud tires? I'm showing my age here. They are old school mud tires, but can they ever go thru some mud!
Haven't heard of those two tires. However, I do know about the Buckshots and Super Swampers. I'll never use those tires for what they were meant to do as it's a pavement princess lol.