Is 5w-30 any good for my 1.6JTD?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Aug 10, 2019
Messages
7
Location
Croatia
Hi guys!

I'm new here, although i have been reading various threads for some time now... Decided to register because i have a problem (duh). Anyway, to shorten the story, i live in Croatia EU (mostly warm climate), own a Fiat Bravo II, 1.6Mjet 88Kw/300nM (120ps), 2011, 160k Km (~100k miles), it has DPF. I do about 10-12k km a year and this last year i drowe on Mobil1 ESP Formula 5w-30 (C2/C3). In general i can't say i had any problems with that oil, DPF indicator never turned on (AFAIK) even though my wife and i mostly drive short distances in the city. I do take the car on a freeway once or twice a month to "blow some steam off" (can't remember the right term :))... Car does not burn oil, when checking the dip-stick after 12k km, oil loss is negligible... But there is one issue i have, it's the click-clack sound when the engine is cold, i believe it's the valves. When cold, the engine is "lazy" and a bit loud, gas pedal response is a bit slow. I never put my foot down when the engine is cold, but when it reaches working temp all the simptoms dissapear... So, i'm not sure, but i would guess that 5w-30 is a bit thin for this engine, taking the warm/hot climate (especially in summer) in consideration. AFAIK, the engine demands Fiat 9.55535-S1 and ACEA C2 oil spec. Some local "experts" suggested i go with a 5w-40, others say nothing except 5w-30, so i hope you understand my dilemma... Can you please suggest what oil would be best (price/performance wise) for this small displacement JTD turbo diesel (with a DPF)? Thank you very much.
 
Click-Clack noise when the engine is cold and goes away when it warms up sounds like piston slap to me.
Sometime when you have cold-started the engine, open the hood and listen at different places in the engine compartment. Does the noise seem to be coming from the upper or lower part of the engine?
M1 5w30 ESP is pretty thick for a 30-weight, and I guess you could try a 5w40. But I don't think it will silence piston slap.
My Camaro has had piston slap since new and I have tried many different oils (light and heavy 30's), but none of them silenced cold-start piston slap.
I have found that if I rev the engine to above 1700 rpm when cold, the piston slap goes away.
Other than that, I just turn up the radio. 273,000 miles, and it still runs fine, so I'm past worrying about it.
 
Sounds like normal Fiat engine noise to me
laugh.gif

Without DPF I used Total Quartz 9000 Energy 5W40 on my Fiat diesel (1,9L, not same engine), it quietened it a lot on cold starts.

With the DPF I guess we can't recommend this oil. I'd try the Quartz Ineo first instead (it has quite a lot of moly and low ash)...no I don't have Total shares
wink.gif
 
Thank you all for your replies...

So, @Popsy you are suggesting i try "Quartz Ineo ECS 5W-30 DPF"? Although i can't find any tech specs for this oil i see positive reviews and it's actually realy cheap at the moment im my local store... 5L is around 30e
Any thoughts on Castrol Magnatec 5W-30 C2 which is ACEA C2 and has Fiat 9.55535-S1 spec, or Motul 8100 X-Clean FE 5W-30 which also has Fiat 9.55535-S1 but complies C2 and C3?
 
Last edited:
http://www.lubs-products-database.total.com/gallery/ORIGINALS/visuels/23000/23437

https://www.oil-club.ru/forum/uploads/monthly_06_2016/post-2-0-43845100-1465547515.jpg

There is a very important difference between C2 and C3 , look it up :
https://www.acea.be/uploads/news_documents/ACEA_European_oil_sequences_2016_update_REV_2.pdf

Although SAPS requirements are identical, C3 mandates HTHS visc.>3.5cP .

Your Mobil1 ESP Formula 5w-30 is C3 oil, addressing the requirement of C2 oils too.

https://www.mobil.com/English-HU/Passenger-Vehicle-Lube/pds/GLXXMobil-1-ESP-Formula-5W30

Although lacking the formal Fiat approval(lots of oils say "FIAT XXXX preformance level" or "meets or exceeds FIAT XXXX specification" which is NOT the same as having it approved by FIAT -and that costs $$$...) I'd still choose it over a C2 oil.

It's up to you whether to go to a 5w-40 C3 oil or better yet 0w-40 C3, it would not hurt. Look for a MB 229.51 or 229.52 approval.
https://www.mobil.com/English-RO/Passenger-Vehicle-Lube/pds/GLXXMobil-1-ESP-X3-0W40
https://bevo.mercedes-benz.com/bevolisten/229.51_en.html
https://bevo.mercedes-benz.com/bevolisten/229.52_en.html

About oil level/consumption--one cannot be sure whether there is no fuel dilution,especially with DPF frequent regen cycles or short distance driving,have this in mind too.
I am not sure if I'd run it over 10K km with a Cx oil (city driving,short distances).What does the manual say about oil change under "severe conditions"?
 
I was suggesting the Total Ineo first 0W30, the 5W30 ECS is nothing exceptional.

Alternatively the Rubia TIR 9900FE 5W30... or like said above a 40 grade on the Mercedes lists. But I don't see a thicker oil helping when cold?

As far as lazyness and noise when cold, mine, although not at all comparable since much older and not same engine, is behaving similarly. On the plus side, it starts very well when cold (ever watched cold start videos?). I always thought Fiat was retarding the injection timings a lot when cold, but I'm probably wrong.

Oh, and also I'd change the oil a bit more often.
What filter are you using? If it's a Fiat made in China by UFI, the sometimes caused noise on my car at startup. I generally use Hengst or Purflux.
 
I'd definitely stay away from this:
http://www.fuel-economy.lubricants.total.com/documents/pdf/total_quartz_ineo_first_0w-30_gb.pdf

Rubia TIR 9900FE 5W30 will be fine if oil consumption is in fact low.

Well all engines are sluggish when cold.Do Fiat really retard the timing when cold?

Ain't much of a difference between 5w-30 and 5w-40 cold crank viscosities,especially considering Croatian weather conditions.

Doesn't this engine use cartridge oil filter elements? I would not expect one to make a whole lotta difference. Spin-on is a different story..Mann-Hummel have been flawless for me.
 
@Rollins
Quote
Although lacking the formal Fiat approval(lots of oils say "FIAT XXXX preformance level" or "meets or exceeds FIAT XXXX specification" which is NOT the same as having it approved by FIAT -and that costs $$$...) I'd still choose it over a C2 oil.

It's up to you whether to go to a 5w-40 C3 oil or better yet 0w-40 C3, it would not hurt. Look for a MB 229.51 or 229.52 approval.
https://www.mobil.com/English-RO/Passenger-Vehicle-Lube/pds/GLXXMobil-1-ESP-X3-0W40
https://bevo.mercedes-benz.com/bevolisten/229.51_en.html
https://bevo.mercedes-benz.com/bevolisten/229.52_en.html

About oil level/consumption--one cannot be sure whether there is no fuel dilution,especially with DPF frequent regen cycles or short distance driving,have this in mind too.
I am not sure if I'd run it over 10K km with a Cx oil (city driving,short distances).What does the manual say about oil change under "severe conditions"?


Thx, i will consider ESP-X3-0W40, just have to check if it is available here... Not really sure, but i think 8-10k is recommended when in "severe conditions", because the car is declared to have prolongued oil-change intervals - normally on 15k (mixed conditions) and 20k if driven exclusivly on the highway... So i like to believe 10-12k is not excessive all things considered, but i agree - less is always better.

@Popsy
Quote
I was suggesting the Total Ineo first 0W30, the 5W30 ECS is nothing exceptional.

Alternatively the Rubia TIR 9900FE 5W30... or like said above a 40 grade on the Mercedes lists. But I don't see a thicker oil helping when cold?

As far as lazyness and noise when cold, mine, although not at all comparable since much older and not same engine, is behaving similarly. On the plus side, it starts very well when cold (ever watched cold start videos?). I always thought Fiat was retarding the injection timings a lot when cold, but I'm probably wrong.

Oh, and also I'd change the oil a bit more often.
What filter are you using? If it's a Fiat made in China by UFI, the sometimes caused noise on my car at startup. I generally use Hengst or Purflux.


Rubia 9900FE 5W30 is available here but only in 20L cans, costs about 150e for that amount... Never had any problems with cold starts, the engine usually start almost immediately. Don't know about retarding the injection timings, so no comment there
smile.gif

I use Mahle filters, so no worries...

@Rollins
Quote
Rubia TIR 9900FE 5W30 will be fine if oil consumption is in fact low.

Well all engines are sluggish when cold.Do Fiat really retard the timing when cold?

Ain't much of a difference between 5w-30 and 5w-40 cold crank viscosities,especially considering Croatian weather conditions.

Doesn't this engine use cartridge oil filter elements? I would not expect one to make a whole lotta difference. Spin-on is a different story..Mann-Hummel have been flawless for me.


Ok, i'll have that in mind... About the oil filter, i'm not sure but i think i can use cartridge and a close-case filter. Was thinking on something like THIS
 
Last edited:
If you want to give 5w-40 a try, look up
https://bevo.mercedes-benz.com/bevolisten/229.51_en.html
... for options.
Castrol products should be easy to find.

Or this:
https://d23zpyj32c5wn3.cloudfront.n...00_X-clean_5W-40__28GB_29.pdf?1492017640

IMHO the present oil is a good choice of yours but if you'd like some added (reserve in) protection in the hot summer weather then give 5w-40 ACEA C3 a try.

Yes,very hard to find HDEO in less than 20l.packaging,alas.

I would never extend the oil change interval to the optimistic lengths specified in the owner's manual with a ACEA Cx oil in an engine with 4.5l. sump . With your type of use(city driving) I would not go over 10K ..and probably less if it happens to be used mostly in the winter months during a given OCI.
I don't know if you have any access to local surveys on diesel fuel quality(or at least on some of its properties like bio-component %) but you'd better check out Infineum Winter Diesel Fuel Quality Survey :

https://www.infineuminsight.com/media/2228/infineum-wdfqs-2018-v10-14112018.pdf
https://www.infineuminsight.com/media/1049/infineum-wdfqs-2016-13032017.pdf
https://www.infineum.com/media/80722/wdfs-2014-full-screen.pdf

The fuel lubricity result for Croatia is not far from the limit (HFRR, μm 460 (max)). I was under the impression that the 7%min. FAME content was mandatory by EU legislation. Turns out that it is either not the case...or many of the EU sellers just don't care...

Yep, this type of filter I had in mind.
 
Thanks man, for all the info... I'm definitely aiming for Motul 8100 X-clean 5W-40, it's even on sale now in a local store (5l ~ 40e).
I will order it now and that filter i mentioned before...
cheers3.gif
 
Originally Posted by Antony013
Thanks man, for all the info... I'm definitely aiming for Motul 8100 X-clean 5W-40, it's even on sale now in a local store (5l ~ 40e).
I will order it now and that filter i mentioned before...
cheers3.gif


Oil you are using is not an issue. Mobile ESP Formul 5W30 has KV100 at 12.1, which is on the verge of being 5W40 oil. You can most definiately try something thicker but I highly doubt you will gain anything.
I know exactly what kind of driving conditions you are facing with (ja sam ti nekad bio komsija), and thicker oil will not be useful. You want something that is not too thick for city driving. Noise could be or could not be addressed by thicker oil. I for example used in VW CC 2.0T several times Mobil1 0W40, but engine was smoothest using Castrol Edge 0W30. Now, in Croatia you have available Castrol Edge 0W30 ACEA C3 oil.
Also, hot weather in Croatia is absolutely NOT an issue for ANY ACEA C3 oils. Those oils work perfectly fine in climates in places such as Arizona or Nevada, and trust me, Croatian summer is refrigerator for those places. However, winter in Croatia can be sometimes pretty harsh (well depending on part of the country) and considering city regimes in Croatia, you want oil that is on a bit thinner side of ACEA C3. So, I would avoid W40 oils in this case.
Again, consider Castrol 0W30 ACEA C3.
If you look under "Odjeljak 3" you will see that oil is 50-75% PAO based, or true synthetic oil.
Castrol 0W30 C3 SDS

Also, KV100 of this oil is 12.3, and KV100 12.5 is where W40 oils start. So this is very, very thick W30 oil:
Castrol 0W30 C3 Technical Data
 
Last edited:
I suspect your clattering is just diesel knock. Diesels are always pretty noisy until they warm up, on top of this a lot of manufacturers leave the EGR open when the engine is cold to force exhaust gases through the EGR cooler which helps to speed up the warm up time. This is probably why your engine feels sluggish when it is cold.
 
Originally Posted by edyvw
Originally Posted by Antony013
Thanks man, for all the info... I'm definitely aiming for Motul 8100 X-clean 5W-40, it's even on sale now in a local store (5l ~ 40e).
I will order it now and that filter i mentioned before...
cheers3.gif


Oil you are using is not an issue. Mobile ESP Formul 5W30 has KV100 at 12.1, which is on the verge of being 5W40 oil. You can most definiately try something thicker but I highly doubt you will gain anything.
I know exactly what kind of driving conditions you are facing with (ja sam ti nekad bio komsija), and thicker oil will not be useful. You want something that is not too thick for city driving. Noise could be or could not be addressed by thicker oil. I for example used in VW CC 2.0T several times Mobil1 0W40, but engine was smoothest using Castrol Edge 0W30. Now, in Croatia you have available Castrol Edge 0W30 ACEA C3 oil.
Also, hot weather in Croatia is absolutely NOT an issue for ANY ACEA C3 oils. Those oils work perfectly fine in climates in places such as Arizona or Nevada, and trust me, Croatian summer is refrigerator for those places. However, winter in Croatia can be sometimes pretty harsh (well depending on part of the country) and considering city regimes in Croatia, you want oil that is on a bit thinner side of ACEA C3. So, I would avoid W40 oils in this case.
Again, consider Castrol 0W30 ACEA C3.
If you look under "Odjeljak 3" you will see that oil is 50-75% PAO based, or true synthetic oil.
Castrol 0W30 C3 SDS

Also, KV100 of this oil is 12.3, and KV100 12.5 is where W40 oils start. So this is very, very thick W30 oil:
Castrol 0W30 C3 Technical Data


Well, it makes sense for sure (bivši susjede ;)). Lucky i haven't ordered yet, so now i have another dilemma in my mind xD but nvm... I live in Dalmacija (if that means anything), it's a warm near sea part of the country.
We have mild winters and hot/very hot summers... After much reading on the subject, i will for sure look for a 0w-30 C3 oil, preferably Castrol or Motul.


Originally Posted by Bailes1992
I suspect your clattering is just diesel knock. Diesels are always pretty noisy until they warm up, on top of this a lot of manufacturers leave the EGR open when the engine is cold to force exhaust gases through the EGR cooler which helps to speed up the warm up time. This is probably why your engine feels sluggish when it is cold.


Yeah, i suppose you are right, even though i hear many people swear that their engines will run much smoother/quieter just by switching to the proper oil... I guess there is truth in that too, as i know from my personal experience with my last car (Seat Leon I 1.9TDI FR), it would run much quieter after the oil change - even when cold. Especially after going from a mediocre to high quality oil... Anyway i am always impressed when i drive in my friends BMW 118d 143PS, it is sooo smooth and quiet, even in high rpm - i guess i'm a bit jelous
smile.gif
 
Just to let everyone know finally, i bought 5L of Castrol Edge FST 0W-30 (C3) and a Mehle oil filter
eek.gif

I hope to exchange the oil tommorow, i'll post my impressions after that... Thank you everyone
11.gif


20190812_174235.jpg
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by Antony013
Thanks man, for all the info... I'm definitely aiming for Motul 8100 X-clean 5W-40, it's even on sale now in a local store (5l ~ 40e).
I will order it now and that filter i mentioned before...
cheers3.gif


Hi,
Your engines clutter noise when cold is probably just a normal diesel noise when cold. I had 2.0 mjet Bravo years back - very similar engine, just different stroke IIRC, and now have 1.9 16v mjet and 1.9 8v mjet. Both are noisy when cold, especially the 8 valve. It is normal. PSA are more refined, VW, for example is not - speaking of contemporary engines.
With mjet 2 engines FIAT/AR modified valve train - roller type now and thus requires low HT-HS oils. That would be C2 oils. However, personally, you can't go wrong with high HT-HS C3 oils. Really any would do- FIAT spec is not required as only few had it. An C3 with BMW LL4 or MB 229.51 will do great. Dexos 2 is alternative too, that was/is what Opel used in these engines.
Motul x clean is priced well and is good oil, Mobil ESP too, but expensive here. MANN and Mahle are first class filters, avoid UFI.
 
Last edited:
So in Dalmacija you do have hot summers, comparatively speaking to the rest of Europe. Is it that hot? No. I have spent a lot of time in Dalmacija, and never had a feeling my eyes will boil over and then jump out. I did spend a lot of time n Las Vegas, and that is feeling you have in mid July. Yet, my father in law runs 5W20 oil in Honda Pilot.
Castrol FST 0W30 is really, really good choice, and I would be running that if we had it available in the US, but we do not.
As for clatter, I would say it is normal FIAT thing. I owned Lancia Lybra 2.4 JTD, and holy moly did it have clatter. But it made more than 500k. Also, BMW engines will be smoother, so do not compare it.
 
I have spent a lot of time in Dalmacija, and never had a feeling my eyes will boil over and then jump out. I did spend a lot of time n Las Vegas, and that is feeling you have in mid July. Yet, my father in law runs 5W20 oil in Honda Pilot.

Yeah, but it's a dry heat, lol!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top