HT/HS and shear

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jun 24, 2004
Messages
14,505
Location
Top of Virginia
My '07 Corolla has 5W-30 on the oil cap and in the owner's manual, but a TSB by Toyota says that 5W-20 is now preferred. I've got 5W-20 in it now...no problems.

I've recently started learning about HT/HS viscosity, and what it means. I generally understand the kinematic viscosity numbers, and understand that the shearing of oil reduces these viscosity numbers. Some oils appear to shear out of grade after so many thousands of miles. It appears that 5W-30 conventional oils are really at a 20W oil after a few thousand miles.

But does the HT/HS number lower also? I understand that the minimum HT/HS viscosity for 5W-20 and 5W-30 oils are 2.6 cP and 2.9 cP respectively. Figuring that I'll see absolutely no change in fuel economy between the two oil grades (I have not in our minivan), I reckon I'll use 5W-30 in it next time just for the better HT/HS viscosity. But if the 5W-30 oil shears down to a "5W-20" after a few thousand miles, do I lose the benefit of the higher HT/HS also? Does the HT/HS viscosity...well...lose viscosity as the miles pile on, as the kinematic viscosity tends to do?

Sorry if this has already been covered before...the search engine never seems to find what I'm looking for, even if I know I've read it here before.

Thanks.
 
The % change in HTHS is approximately 1/2 the % change in kinematic viscosity (due to permanent viscosity loss). You could "run the #'s" on 5W-30 oils that shear vs 5W-20 oils that also shear but not as much.
 
As I understand it, HTHS is largely supported by the base oil. When the VIIs collapse, little HTHS loss will occur.
 
Yes the high temp, high shear viscosity drops as well, although it's correlation with the kinematic viscosity @100C isn't as simplistic as JAG would suggest.

TS
 
So it sounds like the HT/HS viscosity will most probably remain higher in a 5W-30 oil, even if the kinematic viscosity does shear down to the 20W range?
 
HTHS drop should be much smaller than overall viscosity drop. Seems this was discussed somewhere on this site this year. Just can't remember where.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top