Originally Posted by brages
So...
I'm a fan of manual transmissions; I find they are more enjoyable to drive and I believe that they are more durable and economical than autos. I have heard the today's new automatics are great, but I drive older (cheaper) cars, so it will be a few years before I can agree or disagree. At least by then, we will have a good picture of the durability of today's wonder-automatics.
Anyway, one of the reasons I like manuals is the instant response. I can anticipate a corner or opening in traffic and be shifted into the right gear. Then, when it's time to GO, just mash down the gas pedal and the car goes, no torque converter slipping, no waiting for a kickdown in gear.
Recently, I bought my first turbo car, a Volvo S40 T5 with a 6 speed manual. Now, this car has a fairly large displacement engine (2.5 5-cyl) for its size and has a fairly small, low-pressure turbo. So you would think it would spool up quickly, and the lag at low RPM's wouldn't be too bad. And it's not a peaky power delivery; it's a flat torque curve that comes on at low rpms, 1500 to 2k.
BUT, what I'm coming to realize is that the turbo lag is giving me a similar sensation to a "slushbox" automatic. Instead of hitting the gas and getting an instant response, I press the accelerator pedal, wait just a bit for the boost to build and then accelerate. And, yeah, it's kind of a fun sensation to feel the boost hit, but it's also annoying... instead of power output being just a function of rpm and throttle, now it's a function of rpm, throttle, and time.
So I'm wondering if anybody else has a similar feeling. Does turbo lag take away from the instant throttle response that makes manuals fun to drive? Does it just seem like turbos work better with automatics anyway, because the time to kick down gives time for boost to build? It seems like more small cars are going the turbo route these days. And everybody says they have "eliminated lag" but I am skeptical...
This is exactly why I have no regrets getting the AT in my BMW, it performs incredibly well and has manners to fit both sporty and comfort situations. These modern high-performance autos, and even *some* CVTs in less sporty applications, are actually better suited for turbocharged engines IMO. While twin scroll, low inertia, and even twin charged setups are doing a lot to reduce lag, it isn't completely gone and since transmissions like the ZF 8AT in my BMW and even Honda's current CVT can operate faster than we humans can operate a manual it helps mitigate lag.