With new entries to the High Mileage Oil party - what would be your top choice followed by one or two other high mileage oil choices - if your favorite was not available ? Synthetic or Semi - Synthetic unless you have a Conventional choice that you think stands up really well . Thanks in advance for replies !
High Mileage Oil Choice?
- Thread starter ChrisD46
- Start date
- Status
I'd go with Pennzoil.
M1 HM for syn. Maxlife or Castrol for syn blend. WM has all of these on sale from time to time. Right now Maxlife is 15.88 for 5 qts locally. M1 goes for 22.45 on sale. Right now it is $25-26 for 5 qts.
Maxlife has a good reputation but fixing the problem your trying to cure with different oil is even better
Pennzoil. I use it with both my older vehicles and they seem to work the best for me. Maxlife is good too.
Originally Posted By: ChrisD46
With new entries to the High Mileage Oil party - what would be your top choice
Originally Posted By: Quattro Pete
So, from that perspective, it's going to be either M1 HM 10w-30 or 40, or the new Castrol Edge HM 10w-40.
My favorites are Penn HM and Castrol HM since both are still thick for grade which I prefer in a HM oil.
Have had the Sebring on Maxlife for years though, excellent stuff.
Originally Posted By: ChrisD46
With new entries to the High Mileage Oil party - what would be your top choice followed by one or two other high mileage oil choices - if your favorite was not available ? Synthetic or Semi - Synthetic unless you have a Conventional choice that you think stands up really well . Thanks in advance for replies !
Last edited:
Nick1994
$100 site donor 2023
I'm running Mobil 1 HM in the 1970 Beetle currently and about to change the Jeep Cherokee's oil over to Mobil 1 HM.
- Joined
- Dec 30, 2006
- Messages
- 29,570
Mobil 1 and Pennzoil.
M1 HM cut oil consumption in my Grand Marquis from 2500mi qt to less than a quart in 5K mi... After changing to M1 there was probably a half qt loss in first 1500 mi and since has used far less... It was never quite full after change(approx 4/5 full) and I've added approx 1/2 qt, still not down to add and it's coming up on 7K mi...
Originally Posted By: TFB1
M1 HM cut oil consumption in my Grand Marquis from 2500mi qt to less than a quart in 5K mi... After changing to M1 there was probably a half qt loss in first 1500 mi and since has used far less... It was never quite full after change(approx 4/5 full) and I've added approx 1/2 qt, still not down to add and it's coming up on 7K mi...
Mobil Super High Mileage.
PHM has always worked for me..Great stuff my only problem is their jugs that don't have the tamper proof oil cap leak !!..
I used maxlife red bottle (semi syn) in a Saturn sc2 with decent results Then went to their white bottle HM full syn. Still not bad and smoking and co consumption went down. Then I figured I would go Mobil since the prices were so close and I prefer Mobil. With this the little Saturn did best on. The Mobil Super is semi syn and a bargain at Walmart.
So my choices are:
Mobil 1 HM (syn)
Mobil Super HM (semi syn)
I've settled on MaxLife full syn
Their 5w30 version meets numerous current specs including SN, GF-5, and dexos
I was never really a Valvoline fan, but after playing with the Lubrizol Comparison Tool... the MaxLife was the BEST oil on many different metrics.
- Status
