I normally use deodorant only but do alternate too with anti perspirant. I have found Speed Stick works really well it’s cheap and effective at least for me. I also alternate with Right Guard, Old Spice, Arrid, Gillette, Dove for Men, Mitchum, Arm and Hammer. Many other ones. So yeah I’ve used pretty much everything and it all works for me. I usually will buy whatever is on sale. I especially like the Irish Spring and Musk scents of the Speed Stick.
So try some different ones and see if you can find one that will work eventually. There are tons more brands than I listed too. Also I’ve heard from some people that stick deodorant doesn’t work for them so they use a spray or roll on and it seems to work better.