I would go for the muff pipe cutter. Lighter, more cutters, more suitable to filter wall thickness. But is 3.25" big enough?
I have heard people have issues trying to use the big boy plumbing pipe cutter on (smaller) oil filters.
Of the two, I'd try the first. I remember someone here trying the pipe cutter and said it crushed the filter can.
I got the one from Summit Racing for Christmas. It works fine, but on a filter smaller than 3" OD the filter doesn't hit the guide wheels. But, it works with a few turns.
Summit Filter cutter