I’m assuming the 09 Sonata is not one of Hyundai’s engines that suffers from their oil consumption/lower bearing campaign. And if so, I like Hyundai, they’ve come a long way. I find these cars to be super reliable. Shops all around my area say the same thing...we don’t do anything to these Hyundai’s and Kia’s, just maintenance, tires and brakes. I have seen some pretty rusted out - subframes - but I believe there was a campaign for that too at one point. I have heard from multiple people that they are not good in the snow (for a front wheel drive car) and this is coming from experienced winter drivers. But if where You live doesn’t get snow...I would definitely chose the Sonata over the Cruz.
Someone mentioned a few different Toyota’s...definitely have that boring appliance feel/look, but man I’ll tell yeah...it’s true what they say. Those cars are just built right. They really are. They are made to be pounded and just keep on going with very minimal repair. I’ve never seen anything like Toyota’s, in terms of quality and almost over-engineering and build. I’ve never seen cars get neglected and abused like I see family hauling Toyota’s. And they just reward those under deserving owners for 100’s of thousand of miles. And the ones that do take care of them, save $1,000’s of dollars longterm with these things. I think the Honda’s look and drive better, but they seem to have taken a dip in reliability.