I'm just saying if the oil was as bad as you said it was ,it would be all over the internet. Your negative review on edge is one of the only negative reviews I've ever seen anywhere on the internet. They are few and far between. Maybe you got a bad jug, idk. I've run it for a long time and it's never come out looking like that on a paper towel.
The VCM of the 2.4 L in my 2016 Honda CR-V is one of the main reasons I use PUP (though in 0W-20), not 5W-30 but PUP of any viscosity is an oil that has very high cleaning, very good lubricating at all the temperatures it sees, and one of the lowest NOAC numbers. If you order 2 or more of the 5 liter jugs Walmart will send them to you for free, and usually PUP is the same price or only a dollar more then PP. Walmart seldom sells PUP in stores around here and when the do the shelf for the 5 Liter is empty and the 1 quart is way over priced. But by mail order the 5 Liter jugs is is a good deal.