Any Anti-Freeze better than none?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Sep 28, 2011
Messages
35
Location
Dorset,England
So I'm driving home with the missus and see a young kid lifting the bonnet of his VW Polo on the opposite side of the road with loads of steam rising from the engine bay and i knew what he was going to do before he did it-thats right he undid the radiator cap unleashing steam all over his face and hands.
At that stage I was more concerned with the possibility that the boy had burns on his face and hands so with limited knowledge of first aid thought we needed to pull over to help. Luckily he seemed ok with just some minor burns to his hands-offered to take him to casualty but he declined as he was keen to sort his car and get to work.
He said he didn’t understand why the car had overheated when it was so cold so I explained about the fact that the water in the radiator was icy mush and this stopped the hot coolant from the block circulating through the radiator. He didn’t know if the car had any anti freeze in it as he only had the car for a month but the previous owner had told him he had replaced the radiator so my guess is when the radiator got replaced he saved some money by refilling with water knowing he was going to sell the car shortly-what a low life!
Anyway drove him about ½ mile to an auto parts shop and picked up 2 litres of G30 coolant-we managed to get most of the coolant in the car and the car started and seemed to run ok with no obvious leaks. Advised him to check the level when cold before he left work and to get it into a garage to check the anti freeze strength in case we continue to get -10c night temperatures as he said he knew nothing about working on cars.
My guess is he wont take my advice and will drive it until something else goes wrong but I felt good that I had helped someone with the bit of knowledge I’ve picked up over the years.
We rightly get concerned about using the correct type of coolant for our cars but in his case any type of anti freeze at a 50% concentration would have been better than a boil up with possible head gasket damage.
 
Iirc, g12+ is the right coolant for VW, but something is better than nothing, and the scenario of green mixing with oat to create brown sludge likely isn't an issue here...
 
Personally, for a short term get-er-home in a warm climate, straight water is better than the wrong antifreeze.

In a climate where what happened here is an issue (coolant freezing in the radiator, resulting in an overheat) I'd have to say that probably the safest thing would be old-school green or or one of the G-series (G-05 being my go-to type). Conventional has a high dose of silicates so it isn't long-life, but it doesn't have anything like 2EHA that will outright HARM any cooling system in the short term. The ONLY issue with silicates is long-term precipitation, nothing at all in the short run. When time allows, thoroughly flush and go back to the recommended coolant.

You could also make an argument for (gasp) DexCool in that the 2EHA is also not likely to do any outright harm in the course of hours or days and that it can be flushed out safely.


So short answer: yes, any coolant is better than none in sub-freezing weather.
 
Actually BASF Glysatin G30 IS approved for use in any VW today.

I've never understood why we in the USA cannot by Glysantin products.
 
Awfully nice of you, most people(in the us anyway) would have driven right by without the slightest bit of concern for the potentially injured, let alone have any concern for the vehicle.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top