I'd stick with the Yokos myself. In my experience, Goodyears have had low grip, bad treadwear, and high prices.
Had a set of Eagle ST's last 23k on my S-10 Blazer back in the day. Got 23k (coincidence?) out of the stock Eagle RS-A's on my Neon R/T, then got 25k out of Yoko AVSi's with about...