I decided to go with the Milestar M665's at Sears.
By the time I decided to buy, Sears had put a 5% sale on Tires so I got the M665's at 37$ each. (148$ for 4). 4 x Balance $62, 4 x Road Hazard $25 ($6ish each), 4 x Chrome Valve Stems $16, Tire Disposal $10 and a 6-month 4-wheel alignment...