Cars with better score in JDP's initial quality study tend to do better at long term reliability study. So yes, the IQS is a good indicator for long term reliability for newer cars where long term data are not yet available.
Long's Drugs sells SI-1 for about $4.50 a bottle all the time.
They also have Redline 75w90 for 7 bucks a bottle. However they want $11 for Syntec when they also have RR sits right next to it for $8.
Did you reset the computer between the fill ups when you switch from 87 to 91?
If you don't, the engine computer will not adapt right away and ofcourse you'd see no gain from the higer octane gas.
Description of Test: Replaced existing 20W50 engine oil, GM Dexron III® ATF fluid, and 75W90 differential fluids with Royal Purple's 20W50 Motor Oil, Max ATF® and Max-Gear® 75W90 in a 400 HP ’65 Mercury Comet and tested on full chassis dynamometer.
http://www.royalpurple.com/hotrod1/hr1p1.html