Let's see if I have this right: This is a Nissan Rogue. Vibration starts at 70 mph, but only on newly paved highways. You are in Ohio.
OEM wheels/Hankook tires = No Vibration
OEM wheels/Michelin Primacy = Vibration
OEM wheels/Michelin Cross Country 2 = Vibration
OEM wheels/ Conti ProContact...